FREE SHIPPING Now on Orders Over $79!
Back
To
Top
Hide Description
To
Top
- Pipes and Cigars
- J.C. Newman
- Factory Throwouts
Factory Throwouts
| Profile | |
| Shapes | Churchill, Lonsdale, Robusto |
| Brand: | J.C. Newman |
Welcome Factory Throwouts back to P&C!
We used to sell these budget-saving cigars by the caseload, and now they're back with a new option. Some of the sizes are now available with a sweetened cap.
These value-priced gems come from J.C Newman, and feature either an Ecuadorian sun-grown or a candela wrapper in three different sizes. The color might be off a bit, and the presentation is strictly plain-Jane, but they're tasty and satisfying and start at just over a buck apiece. If you want a flavorful way to fill up the empty space in the humidor, look no further.
Customer Reviews (175)
Overall Rating4.47 out of 5 Based on 171 Ratings Write A Review
Write A Review
Hide Reviews
5 out of 5
5 Star
102
4 out of 5
4 Star
54
3 out of 5
3 Star
10
2 out of 5
2 Star
3
1 out of 5
1 Star
2
Clear Filter
5 out of 5
Pretty much perfect.
Apr 12, 2021
Pretty much perfect.
Moshe G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Very good flavor
Apr 11, 2021
Very good flavor
Ronald B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Great little smoke!
Apr 04, 2021
Great little smoke for the price! Not pretty, but perfect for working in the yard. A few were a little hard on the draw, but overall quite enjoyable.
James L.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Long lasting slow burn Nice
Apr 01, 2021
Long lasting slow burn Nice flavor.
Robert K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Sweet
Mar 30, 2021
Excellent smoke, nice sweet flavor for a long tasteful smoke!
William B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Nice variety of flavors and
Mar 15, 2021
Nice variety of flavors and great price.
Susan R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Factory Throwouts 59 Nat
Mar 07, 2021
The taste is pretty good. Personally they are just a little to long. It takes too long to smoke one, next time I'll look for a smaller cigar.
JOHN S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
These have been a good every-day smoke that is affordable.
Mar 07, 2021
I've been enjoying these. They're smooth and mild. These are a good find. I'll be keeping them stocked in my humidor.
Louis G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great!
Mar 07, 2021
Awesome and cheap!
Moshe G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Great stick for a buck
Mar 02, 2021
Great stick for a buck
Rich V.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
I'm a big fan of
Feb 27, 2021
I'm a big fan of the "Throwouts" for their price and they taste good and most appropriate for my daily winter walks where a high quality cigar's benefits get lost in cold wind. I won't buy the "Sweets" again but only because my pipe tobaccos satisfy my sweet tooth. Recommended.
Thomas M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Amazing deal for the price
Feb 24, 2021
Amazing deal for the price and enjoyable cigars
Anthony W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
good cigar. good price.
Feb 23, 2021
good cigar. good price.
wendy M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Excellent cigar for the price
Feb 20, 2021
#49 is a rather mild cigar that burns cool and even. I've noticed a few spots on most, but it doesn't affect the flavor. Well wrapped with few veins or stems, its a good everyday work or driving cigar. And at just over a buck per stick, the value can't be beat!
Del D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Cigar review
Feb 20, 2021
Just the right length, Flavor is good, Nice slow burning Cigar .
Robert K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
They were for my oldest
Feb 09, 2021
They were for my oldest daughter and she told me that they are enjoyable.
Sean S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Everything i wanted
Feb 05, 2021
Everything i wanted
kelly m.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
These "Throwouts" seem a bit sweeter ...
Feb 03, 2021
Than the other "Throwouts" I have purchased. Packed tighter, which is not distracting and lasts 5 minutes longer which I like. I order these "Throwouts" frequently.
Thomas M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
1 out of 5
dont buy
Jan 29, 2021
dried out and bad aftertaste
Shoaib R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
I am so glad I
Jan 27, 2021
I am so glad I bought these! The flavor is stellar. A huge bargain. These are quality cigars at a fraction of the cost.
Daniel W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar for a great
Jan 25, 2021
Great cigar for a great price
John S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Excellent packing & shipping. Plus,
Jan 23, 2021
Excellent packing & shipping. Plus, I really enjoy this cigar.
John P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Humidor staple
Jan 14, 2021
What a sweetly enjoyable cigar, and at a price point that is free from concern.
Wayne F.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
A very good cigar for
Jan 11, 2021
A very good cigar for the money.
Steven P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good every day cigar for
Jan 07, 2021
Good every day cigar for the money. Mixed filler, but much better than store brands.
anthony j.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Purchased a second time. Good
Jan 04, 2021
Purchased a second time. Good flavor and the right price for a dairy smoke. Will buy again.
michael j.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
I have enjoyed these cigars
Dec 28, 2020
I have enjoyed these cigars more than many that are $10 or more. This is a fantastic cigar for the price. I will buy more.
Jeffery A.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Draws good good cigar for
Dec 27, 2020
Draws good good cigar for the money
fred c.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar
Dec 26, 2020
Great cigar for the money
ron b.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
The Free Cuba cigars are
Dec 26, 2020
The Free Cuba cigars are mild and burn well but are mostly an earthy tobacco flavor. The factory throw outs 59 were more satisfying. They were looser but more flavorful. They had flavors of toasted nuts, hints of cedar and coffee.
Linden P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Use the right cutter and expect a few with off flavor...
Dec 25, 2020
I gave these three stars because although a value packed cigar, the consistency of each left some to be desired. There were, of course, some good quality cigars but 2/3 of the pack either had a fast burn or a bitter smoke to them, a few were even hard. Some wrappers came cracked and the caps are very shallow. That being said the 1/3 of the good cigars was worth it. Do not use a V cutter on these! You are best served with a punch cutter, I use an old .300blk casing from hunting season...
ryan k.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
A Real Nice “Dog Walker”
Dec 23, 2020
I’m very happy with the taste, draw and value. Look, I’m no connoisseur and no big spender with a limited number of taste buds left. 30-40 minute smoke while walking the dog. If you’re like me, you’ll like these.
Thomas M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Very mild, nice flavored cigar.
Dec 23, 2020
Very mild, nice flavored cigar. However, took a very long time to arrive.
Wayne P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good cigar for the price.
Dec 14, 2020
Good cigar for the price.
Willie K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
A great, inexpensive daily smoke.
Dec 09, 2020
A great, inexpensive daily smoke. I enjoy the size and the taste.
Willie K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
This cigar is just what
Dec 08, 2020
This cigar is just what I would expect a bundle cigar to be. It is rolled well,it is mild but not to mild. It is well made with an easy draw and stay lit .very good price.will buy again.
Thomas P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Worth a lot more than they cost
Nov 29, 2020
Smooth, not a major depth of flavor, but would gladly smoke these over much higher priced cigars. Pleasantly auprised
Adam M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Burn nice and even draw
Nov 28, 2020
Burn nice and even draw good smell good hard to get out of rapper.
George W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good flavor and fair draw
Nov 10, 2020
Good flavor and fair draw but great value!
Patrick S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Very mild robust flavor. The
Nov 05, 2020
Very mild robust flavor. The burn was slow and relaxing. Excellent quality.
Paul M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
I like 'em!
Oct 29, 2020
Half of these burn uneven. The few packages I received were fresh, delivered on time, and tasted good. I've also smoked the high end cigars for comparison. Hey, they're cheap and good!
Nathan S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good Cigar!
Oct 29, 2020
Good cigar!
Eric E.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good value nice cigar
Oct 27, 2020
Good value nice cigar
Fred D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory throwout sweet
Oct 24, 2020
Great smoke
Catherine B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good sigar for the price
Oct 16, 2020
Good sigar for the price
L B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good smoke
Oct 06, 2020
burns evenly
Dean H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Nice smoke!!!
Sep 27, 2020
These are the best cigars for the price they have a sweet. Tastes they are one of my favorite cigars!!
Denny R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Not too sweet
Sep 26, 2020
Not too sweet
Tom T.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Smokes great and has a
Sep 16, 2020
Smokes great and has a nice sweet taste.
Demorian M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
NO.59
Sep 14, 2020
Good cigars packed a little to tight,just rolled and squeezed a little bit and they smoked very well.
William G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Lightly sweet, consistent draw through
Sep 13, 2020
Lightly sweet, consistent draw through out each cigar and from one cigar to the next. Burns evenly through the whole cigar. Very good price.
Robert H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
These are good smoking cigars.
Sep 11, 2020
These are good smoking cigars. My friends and I have enjoyed them for a few weeks now. The sweetness is mainly in the wrapper and wears off throughout the smoke bud they are smooth and enjoyable.
Kristopher S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great flavor and great price
Sep 08, 2020
Great flavor and great price .
Mark R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throw-out's 59 Claro
Sep 02, 2020
This is a decent candela or double claro Lonsdale. Mild and slightly sweet. There are few candela wrapped cigars left and this is one is good and reasonably priced.
RAFAEL R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throwouts 49 Nat
Sep 01, 2020
Great smoke at a GREAT price!
Bill H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Nice
Aug 19, 2020
Nice
david l.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
these are very enjoyable
Aug 13, 2020
these are obviously very good cigars and I will be purchasing them again.
Michael G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
"Throwouts" shouldn't be in the title.
Aug 10, 2020
I recently got some cigars for around 5 bucks a pop, for good/nice occasions, however I think I enjoyed these more. Yes they are cheaper quality, but I like the flavor better and I can have 5 to 1😁
Jacob H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good flavor, even burn and
Aug 09, 2020
Good flavor, even burn and good taste.
David Z.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Excellent
Aug 03, 2020
Excellent
Robert C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Sweet
Aug 03, 2020
A good cigar for the price , I always get these because I like the cheaper cigars . Love the sweet taste of these cigars also .
Mark R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar loyal customer
Aug 03, 2020
I have smoked this cigar for 7-8 years. A great value and a long smoke. I have shared with friends and have had the same reaction.
Donald C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
fast
Jul 31, 2020
fast
wally b.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
very nice everyday, affordable smoke
Jul 25, 2020
Very smooth and mellow, nice flavor.
Steve A.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great value for decent cigars
Jul 25, 2020
Great value for decent cigars
Robert G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
A few hot spots and
Jul 15, 2020
A few hot spots and irregular burns, so some wasted cigars.
Terry M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Yum.
Jul 15, 2020
This has to be my favorite sweet cigar. I try more premium smokes but I always come back to these.
Charles W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Wonderful smoke
Jul 14, 2020
Stumbled upon these cigars over a year ago. Wonderful flavor and well-constructed. Often a friend is in need of a cigar on the golf course. Because of these cigars are inexpensive I can gladly help a friend out. They all rave about them. When I go to a cigar parlor and buy an $.68 cigar I usually wish I had just stuck with my Factory Throwouts 99Nat.
Walt M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great
Jul 11, 2020
Great
dennis m.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throwouts 49 Sweet
Jul 10, 2020
The product was just what I wanted & delivered in a timely fashion...
Thomas M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Best tasting value
Jul 09, 2020
Best cheap cigar out there.
John R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Smooth and flavorful.
Jul 07, 2020
Smooth and flavorful.
Jay Z.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great value and taste for
Jun 20, 2020
Great value and taste for the money
DONALD K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Pleasant smoke
Jun 19, 2020
Pleasant smoke
Cameron S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Factory Throwouts 99 Sweet
Jun 16, 2020
I was surprised by these cigars. They smoke great and if it wasn’t for some minor flaws in the color of the wrapper, I’d have thought they were regular priced.
Dan H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
A decent smoke.
Jun 08, 2020
Good smooth smoke at a reasonable price. What's not to like?
Dennis S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Factory throwouts 99
May 18, 2020
These are a good cigar for the price 👌 .
Mark R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great stick for the money
May 07, 2020
These have been my go to daily sticks. They have a good flavor, are cheap, and rarely have draw issues after many bundles smoked.
Robert I.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Beat Deal Out There
May 07, 2020
Amazing deal for the price and the cigars are delicious and have an amazing burn.
Anthony W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Great cigar
Apr 18, 2020
Great cigar
ron b.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Everyday Cigar
Feb 13, 2020
This is a great everyday cigar, and not just because if the price.
Kenton G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
DO NOT BUY!
Feb 06, 2020
I say do not buy, that way when I need to reorder they will not be on back order, GREAT EVERY DAY SMOKES!
Eric✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Factory Throwouts
Jan 28, 2020
They are a good mild smoke
Terry W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
A good daily cigar for
Jan 24, 2020
A good daily cigar for the price. This isn't a premium cigar but you aren't paying premium prices. Once in awhile one will canoe but at the price you're paying you can live with it. The Taste is agreeable not harsh what's a rich smoke.
Joe B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good price
Jan 19, 2020
These may be throw outs but they have great flavor and smell. They are worth getting if you want a good cigar at a good price.
Jeffrey C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Not Bad, Great Price
Jan 01, 2020
A great deal and a nice daily smoker.
Thom K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Mild taste and good flavor
Dec 13, 2019
Mild taste and good flavor
Dennis D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Great deal!
Dec 09, 2019
Great deal!
Eric F.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Not bad and at a
Dec 09, 2019
Not bad and at a fair price
Ray S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
very good
Nov 22, 2019
i just smoke one a day but really enjoy them
Robert P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
factory throwouts 49
Oct 25, 2019
all in all not a bad deal. The taste was good the cigars ashed evenly. To cut the was a little more pressure causing the cigar to draw a bit harder while smoking them. All in all a good deal. I will grab more it is a nice way to keep a few sticks handy for that stress for day.
Michael S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good smoke
Oct 07, 2019
They are a good smoke at a fair price
mark D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
very good
Sep 20, 2019
enjoyable mild flavor
Robert P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Cheap smokes.
Aug 18, 2019
My favorite.
Earl G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good daily smoke
Aug 06, 2019
Easy draw, consistent and good flavor. This could become my new favorite daily indulgence.
Terry C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good every day cigar.
Jul 18, 2019
Good every day cigar.
Ernest W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
bitter sweet
Jun 22, 2019
sweet is right. i smoked these at work with my morning black coffee. i would say it is a great pairing. something bitter with something sweet
Wyatt U.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Do NOT Throw-out!
Jun 18, 2019
Great cigar for a great price!
Sonny H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Good price
May 30, 2019
Good price
Fred D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great taste
May 18, 2019
Originally a little worried that these were just another Swisher--they aren't. Just a hint of honey to tone down the smoke. Very nice. A good value for a daily smoke as well.
Terry C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
A good value for the
May 16, 2019
A good value for the money
Matthew C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Totally awesome thanks
Apr 27, 2019
Totally awesome thanks
Gayle P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
very good every day cigar
Apr 24, 2019
I've tried a lot of lower priced cigars over the last ten years. This one has jumped to the front of the class. Good draw, even burn and mild taste.
Walt M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great smoke!
Apr 19, 2019
Great flavor, burns well, great price.
Dustin K.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Best tasting value
Apr 10, 2019
Can't beat the price for these tasty surprise cheapos.
John R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
#99 factory throw outs
Apr 09, 2019
Good flavor but some are almost impossible to clip.
Kenn W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good smoke
Apr 06, 2019
For the price they aren't bad. Sometimes you get one that burns uneven but it's worth it.
scott h.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
My favorite
Mar 31, 2019
These are my go-to campfire or yard work smoke.
Chuck H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
A not so bad cigar
Mar 31, 2019
A not so bad cigar if you want a quick and pleasant smoke.
Gregory P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good smoke
Mar 23, 2019
Priced a little high but a good cigar. If the price ever goes up I'll stop buying them.
Robert S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Cigars & Pipe tobacco also Corn Cob pipes
Mar 02, 2019
I really have enjoyed the cigars, pipe tobacco and Corn Cob pipes
I have purchased from you.
Dave
David S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Enjoyable Everyday Smoke
Jan 31, 2019
No bells and whistles, just a good smoke with long ash and pleasant room fragrance. What's not to like at this price.
Gerald R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Two thumbs up
Jan 13, 2019
Great smokes,plain and simple
Mark J.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
CIGARS
Jan 03, 2019
GREAT PRICE. VERY GOOD CIGAR TO SMOKE.
TOM F.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
GREAT TO GIVE GUESTS
Dec 20, 2018
Always good to provide a cigar to those friends and family that stop by to see you. These are good enough but not a 5 star cigar. Save those for yourself...
Gerald M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great Price
Nov 06, 2018
Nice cigar, smooth and a just a little sweet tasting. Will buy again.
MARTIN M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good, Value Cigars!
Nov 03, 2018
I'm not a cigar guy, so these seemed like a safe bet, value-wise.
Turned out I was right! These cigars are very pleasant, and well worth the cash. If you're on the fence, definitely give these a try.
Adam H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
excellent cigar, great value, I
Oct 15, 2018
excellent cigar, great value, I have smoked $30.00 cigars and $1.00 cigars
for an everyday smoke it's hard to beat
Louis N.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Not too bad
Oct 01, 2018
I cant complain. Burns good, taste good, no foul after taste. Its not as sweet as i expected but still killer for the price.
Benjamin M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Always Good
Sep 18, 2018
These are consistently good, but I hesitate to recommend them in glowing terms lest they become hard to get. Since I've been smoking them they have gone on back order a couple of times. That is not good.
David M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Enjoyable, Uncomplicated Smoke
Aug 21, 2018
When it's time to take a break and just enjoy a smoke for an hour or so with a cigar that doesn't detract from the enjoyment and flavor of a fine Tennessee sipping whiskey this is a great choice.
Gerald R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
2 out of 5
There are better alternatives out there for budget cigars
Aug 19, 2018
Tight draw, paper thin wrapper that cracks easy, short filler that requires you to keep watching your ash dropping, the ring size is also short changed as I believe it did not physically measured #49. Taste is an objective thing, and I did not like its taste. With many other alternatives in the market at that price level, I will not be buying them again.
William W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
factory throw-outs
Aug 07, 2018
seem great to me
Albert Z.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
"Throw-outs"... I don't think so!
Jul 31, 2018
You'll not beat the quality for the price. Long lasting, burns well, sturdy for when you are working in the yard; and, it's a nice tasting and satisfying smoke.
Paul H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
good dog walking cigar
Jul 19, 2018
A little on the bitter side, but may get better with age.
DAVID S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
great cigar at any price.
Jul 18, 2018
great cigar at any price. I enjoy them very much and really appreciate the value.
daniel z.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
The new go to
Jul 04, 2018
This is the quintessential five cent cigar. It really is just about as good as cigars almost ten times the price.
Charles W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar for the price!
Jun 18, 2018
I bought these on a whim recently and wasn't disappointed! I brought a bunch to a party recently and everyone that tried one loved them! Nice smoking, slightly sweet cigar and it pairs well with a glass of Irish whiskey!
Ian C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
fast
May 31, 2018
fast
walter b.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great Value
May 08, 2018
No complaints at all
Jim W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
I like them fine
May 02, 2018
Good taste and a great price.
Roland P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Very Satisfied
May 01, 2018
I have been smoking these for over a year. Occasionally I will come across one with some sort of defect. No big deal. After all they are "Throw -outs". I enjoy the taste and certainly the price. Very Satisfied.
Michael F.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Great taste but bad draw
Apr 18, 2018
Great buy and flavor , The only complaint I have is that they are rolled too tight and the draw is bad. I had a hard time even keeping it burning. They did arrive on a snowy day and sat on the porch in the snow most the day. They may need to dry out a little.
Chad P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throwout Cigars
Mar 22, 2018
Smooth taste,slow burning,pleasant aroma,great price,what more could you want.
jesse p.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Recommend
Jan 04, 2018
Great value cigar...
Thomas S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Don’t throw these Coronas out
Dec 21, 2017
Great value for the money
Matthew C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
More than just a great value.
Dec 18, 2017
It's not just a great price but most often a good tasting cigar.
John R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Fast
Dec 13, 2017
Great price for a very good cigar
Fred D.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
great
Dec 13, 2017
great
DALE✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Why Not?
Dec 11, 2017
I understand that if your furniture has a defect you have to live with that. Here you have a cigar that would retail at $7ea but due to discoloration it's only a $1. The best way to fill your humidor and keep it full with a great tasting cigar.
Justin T.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
great
Dec 04, 2017
great cigar
Joseph S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Enjoyable
Nov 27, 2017
I really like these and they are cheap! I am a retired person and did not get a golden parachute from an investment bank on Wall Street.
David M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throw-Outs 59 Claro (Corona),
Nov 23, 2017
fine inexpensive smoke. will not hesitate to re-order.
Ron B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Too many plugs
Nov 10, 2017
Otherwise a decent smoke
Herb W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
3 out of 5
Good everyday stick
Sep 15, 2017
Don't be fooled by the name. Very good economical cigar.
Ross B.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
A good smoke
Sep 14, 2017
Like GM said a woman is occasional pleasure but a. Cigar is always a good smoke
gregory d.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Good daily smoke for the $
Sep 10, 2017
Very consistent with taste and draw. Not an overly sweet tip or taste. Just a nice everyday smoke.
Adam G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Cheap and good
Aug 09, 2017
A great yard-gar. Out of 3 bundles I've had only a couple duds and I could still finish them off.
Matt E.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
1 out of 5
Factory 59
Apr 25, 2017
Not as good as many people has stated. But everybody has their own taste. I found the draw to be to tight and taste was not as good as I hoped.
Joseph H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Will re-order
Feb 22, 2017
Will re-order
Reed L.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good Cigar for a man
Jan 21, 2017
Good Cigar for a man that can not afford the top or the line, hard to beat this smoke!
GySgt. U.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar
Jan 17, 2017
Factory throw outs are my favorite cigars so far pipes and cigars is the best site I've used and I will be using it exclusively from now on
John M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigar
Jan 12, 2017
I will definitely be buying these again. I have been pleased with everything I have ever bought from pipes and cigars this is the website I only use and will only use no one has better prices or selection.
John M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
2 out of 5
FACTORY THROWOUTS
Jan 07, 2017
THIS BATCH HAS SOFT TIPS, BURN UNEVEN, AND ARE BITTER. SO FAR THE WORST I HAVE RECEIVED!
WAYNE G.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great cigars for the price
Dec 21, 2016
I don't consider myself a cigar connoisseur. I'm more concerned about good flavor at a reasonable price. The Factory Throwouts meet those standards for me. Great taste at a great value.
David S.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Best bargain anywhere
Dec 09, 2016
Surprisingly good taste and construction. Long steady burn. I've paid a lot more and gotten a lot less out of so-called name or premium brands.
John R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Dave
Dec 02, 2016
Pretty good value for the money, I am pleased.
Dave P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
Great Value!
Oct 30, 2016
I will be buying more of these gems! Excellent smoke for the price. Great value for an afternoon smoke. Can't believe you guys have an offer like this one. I've always been satistfied with everything I have purchased from P & G!
John W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
good value
Jul 02, 2016
good value
Donald T.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throw-Outs 99 Natural ( Churchill )
Jun 16, 2016
An excellent cigar, one of the best I have ever smoked. They are very well made, packed tightly, smoke slowly and last a long time. Last evening the cigar lasted 1 1/2 hours.
Hal O.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Factory Throw-Outs 99 Churchill
May 09, 2016
This is a very good cigar for the money. I will be buying more.
Kenn W.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
As Promised
Apr 15, 2016
I ordered some cigars and pipe tobacco recently. Both are of good quality and came on time. I look forward to future orders.
Maurice H.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
A good flavor
Dec 16, 2015
Yeah, I know..
It's a cheap cigar.
Machine made.
But the flavor is great.
The cigar is inconsistent in that one draws easy and the next does not.
One stays wrapped and another does not or the cap falls off.
Or you find a leak in the wrapper but, the taste is great.
That is why I usually but two bundles a month.
I smoke them, hand them out so others can join me and never run out.
Between I smoke some very good hand rolled but for a good flavorful smoke that
is easily affordable by all, this is it.
Train
Christian P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
GOOD PLACE TO DO BUSINESS.
Dec 13, 2015
THIS IS JUST A GOOD COMPANY TO DO BUSINESS WITH. THEY WILL DO WHOT THEY SAY.
Bobby C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Good cigar
Nov 30, 2015
Better than expected, shipping extremely slow.
Ric C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
A Cheap Cigar
Nov 05, 2015
Ya! I didn't give this 5 stars. I couldn't because it isn't a 5 star cigar. It is however a pleasant smoke that I have enjoyed for quite some time and I think you will too.
Sure, it's rolled of short leaf tobacco causing the ash to flake away if your not careful but the quality of tobacco is reasonable at the least.
I buy 2 bundles a month and still enjoy other cigars. Heheh. A cheap cigar with a good taste.
Train
Christian P.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
2 out of 5
Mediocre smoke, the other reviews are over rating these.
Oct 10, 2015
Not a good cigar but OK at best if you get one with a decent draw. These are leafcut not long filler with what looks like a paper inner wrapper. There are many other good cigars at cheap prices so I won't be purchasing these again.
John R.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Wonderful
Sep 15, 2015
High qual cigars at a wonderful price
Cuyler M.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
Great Inexpensive Cigar
Aug 21, 2015
Great everyday cigar especially for the price! I've had the #49 in various sizes as well and they too are a great everyday smoke...
thomas a.
Was this helpful?
4 out of 5
#99
Aug 20, 2015
Not a terrible cigar . Tasted like wood and leather with a hint of pepper and chocolate. It's not a pretty cigar and ash flaked badly . But for the price they are a steal. I would recommend buying them but store them in a humidor for a couple months and I think the flavor would improve
anthony S.
Was this helpful?
5 out of 5
These cigars are a great
Jul 24, 2015
These cigars are a great smoke and a great value I have been smoking them for over 5 years, and have found them to be of excellent quality.
Donald C.✔ Verified Buyer
Was this helpful?
Customer Testimonials
GL of Howard, SD
Im primarily a pipe smoker and my experience with cigars has been with cheap factory made brands. These are the first hand made cigar I have tried and they ruined factory made cigars for me. Great flavor and room note. I highly recommend them for newbies to the cigar world.
CH of Montfort, WI
I ordered my first bundle of Robustos and tried one as soon as it arrived. It was a mild, sweet, and flavorful smoke and I was pleasantly surprised at the quality. I will be ordering more in the future. It was the best dollar cigar I ever smoked.
GM of TULSA, OK
I have purchased Factory Throughouts No. 99 Churchill for about5 years. They have been consistent in flavor and provide a long smoke (1-1 1/4 hours). Once in about 100 cigars, I find a wrapper that will have a minor "peal off", but for the price this is a minor problem. One thing I have found is that the best way to "cut" the tip is not to cut it, but rather to take a metal "poker" and pierce the tip. I use a pipe tool to do this. A nail will work also.
DC of Wilmington, DE
Customers buying this also buy
