Great News, FREE SHIPPING now on orders over $79!
Back
To
Top
Burley Brawl Pipe Tobacco Samplers
Click the icons below for product information.

Burley Brawl

P&C's Battle of the Blends pits two tobaccos against each other, and you get to vote for your favorite by submitting a review. Best of all, you get both tobaccos at a bargain price. We'll tabulate the votes and announce the winner at a later time.

An all and all out brawl over the Burley pipe tobacco. In this battle we bring to you Scotty's Butternut Burley and Lane Limited Burley Light Without a Bite both are sought after. Here is your chance to get both of these blends and smoke them side-by-side and tell us who you believe is the best of the Burley. 

Burley Brawl Bout includes: 

(1) 3oz Bag of Scotty's Butternut Burley

(1) 3oz Bag of Lane Limited Burley Light Without a Bite

Blend
PackIn StockPriceQtyCart
Pipe Tobacco SamplerIn Stock$12.99
Lane Limited Burley-Light-Without-A-Bite Bulk Shipping Constraints
Per OZIn Stock$2.58
Quantity:
Price:
1
$2.58
2-3
$2.44
4-7
$2.30
8-15
$2.15
16+
$2.06
Scotty's Butternut Burley Shipping Constraints
Per OZIn Stock$3.85
Quantity:
Price:
1
$3.85
2-3
$3.39
4-7
$3.16
8-15
$2.97
16+
$2.79
Shipping Constraints:
  • These items cannot be shipped to a Washington state address.
Add To Wish ListsLearn More
Overall Rating4.6 out of 5 Based on 218 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Burley Brawl”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
163
4 out of 5
4 Star
30
3 out of 5
3 Star
19
2 out of 5
2 Star
4
1 out of 5
1 Star
2
Showing 1-50 of 218 Reviews
5 out of 5
Love it!
Awesome taste and smell. Not too bad of a bite
5 out of 5
My favorite pipe tobacco! Mild
My favorite pipe tobacco! Mild smoking, delicious aroma. What more could you want!
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley
I bought some of this due to the reviews that I read. Then a friend remarked to me how much he enjoyed this blend. I have a very well stocked "cellar" mostly containing aromatic tobaccos which I prefer. After 3 or 4 bowls now in varying pipes both Briar and Corn Cob, I have a new tobacco to add to my favorites list. This is a quality product that provides a great room note, a great taste, and very easily could be an all day smoke. The Burley is wonderful, burns well, and provides maximum enjoyment. I have detected no bite, very little moisture, very little dottle. Being a Burley you do need to use a slow cadence when smoking. Leaves a wonderful aroma on your beard and shirt that makes you want to fill another bowl shortly after the last one. I have added a little Lane Vanilla Black Cavendish in one bowl......wow. Next I am going to add some Nording Labrador Hunter as I can just imagine how that would be enjoyable. I will be ordering a pound or so of the Butternut Burley when I get a few disposable bucks.
3 out of 5
Sorry, not for me!
I'm 80 years old and been a Burley man for 65 of those years. I wanted to love this but was disappointed with it. I found it was not as bite-free as other reviewers. Also, rather sweet. Sorry, that's my honest opinion. I am a card carrying "old codger" and I'll stick with CH, SWR, etc. a tub of LLRR is supposed to get here today and I have high hopes for that one. Semper Fi Mke
3 out of 5
mellow
This is a pretty mellow tobacco. Certainly not the punch in the face flavor that I was expecting.
4 out of 5
Mv1000 bulk
I like it. Smokes well.
5 out of 5
Nuts...
I’m willing to believe the inconsistency here is more on my part than on Ol Scotty’s, but my last batch seemed more nutty. Maybe the bottom of the jar had kept longer and brought it out as it aged and dried? Still I’m happy I’ve got a plenty in stock on the shelf cuz this tobacco is a tasty easy smoke that tickles my Aromatic itch without gooping up my pipe or setting the dogs on my tongue.
5 out of 5
No bite means no Bite great smoke
As a new 3 month pipe smoker former cig. smoker,This blend is a true NO bite with a filling smoke and aroma for beginners and former cigarette smokers.. I can smoke it nice and warm without that tongue bite at all. It is almost like a Prince Albert original but with more aroma that is very nice and mellow...I highly recommend Lane burley light without a bite to anyone especially newcomers to the world of pipe smoking...Quitting cigarettes is hard, but I have conquered that 40 yr. old habit with PC's bulk offers of Lane..I have tried many favorite brands like Capt black but to me they all had a lil bite,except for PA, So I looked into Lanes tobaccos and found some like this one I can smoke all day and inhale mildly from time to time with no sting or bite.... I give this blend 5 stars
5 out of 5
Very pleasant smoking
This is my favorite tobacco, very smooth and tasty with a nice room note.
4 out of 5
Great Blend!
Just received this in the mail today and have smoked a couple of bowls; it is really great. I also ordered some Lane Limited 1Q and I have to admit the two are pretty close, not sure which one I like best yet. Butternut and vanilla is what I get out of it. Burns cool, no tongue bit. This blend is great and I would highly recommend it.
5 out of 5
As advertised. It does not
As advertised. It does not have a bite, and it smokes sweet
4 out of 5
pipie tobacco
good selection of tobacco
5 out of 5
A cool smoke after a
A cool smoke after a few bowl's I really like it
5 out of 5
I will be buying more of this!
I tried this because of the good reviews and I was not disappointed. This is a very mild and tasty smoke with no bite.
3 out of 5
Hope
I had high hopes but had a big let down. I like lane burly and black !!!
5 out of 5
Great tobacco
Great light tobacco
5 out of 5
Scotty’s butternut burly
Great, smoke it every morning with my coffee
5 out of 5
Simply Wonderful
I‘ve never given any tobacco such a high rating before, but this tobacco definitely deserves it. I‘m a Burley fan, and enjoy slightly aromatic tobaccos, and this blend of, I believe, 5 different Burleys, imparts a wonderful nutty flavor. It‘s mild, slightly moist, lights right off and dosen’t require but a couple od relights. There is zero tongue bite. I have several differential tobaccos on hand, but it seems like I tend to reach for this nearly all the time. My favorite pipe shape is a pot, and this tobacco smokes and tastes best in my Savenelli 316 KS. I belong to a pipe and cigar club and am the only dedicated pipe smoker, and while smoking a bowl of this stuff, it‘s not unusual for one or more cigar smokers to comliment the room note. Give it a try.
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley!!!
Nice Pipe tobacco and NO Bite! If you have a problem with tongue bite or burn, try this tobacco.
5 out of 5
Smooth
Great smoke - slow burn, all day smoke
5 out of 5
Awesome!!!
I loved this blend from my first pipeful.
4 out of 5
Good for blending with black
Good for blending with black cavendish
5 out of 5
Very nice smoke
Very smooth. Slight sweet flavor with no bite.
5 out of 5
Excellent
Excellent
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley
Great smoke. Fast shipping and great customer service.
5 out of 5
A great smoke!
A great smoke!
4 out of 5
a very good substitute, or,
a very good substitute, or, second favorite smoke
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley is a favorite
Mellow and delicious. An aromatic with flavor that goes beyond mere room note. Especially tasty finish.
5 out of 5
BL/WB
Have used this mixed with Lane BCA since the 1980s. It is a great combination mixed 3 BCA to 1 BL/WB, which is my current mixed. I have also mixed 1 to 1, which is also good. The best part is the aroma which almost everyone likes. I get compliments regularly.
5 out of 5
All day.
This is my all day smoke. I burn 3 to 4 bowls of this a day, sometimes more on my days off. It's smoothe as silk with a nutty flavor. I gave a buddy some and he mixed it with some Lane Cavendish and he said it was even better that way. I smoke it all by itself and I haven't found anything that matches it. Highly recommended.
5 out of 5
great smoke
This is great and one of my new favorites nice and light good flavor good smell no bite that I could sense and I do plan on buying some more of this when I'm through with what I got again this is some very good stuff recommended
5 out of 5
Great
Great
5 out of 5
Well Named, Well Lit, Well Smoked!
When this arrived I was heading out to pick up a co-worker that needed a lift and hastily packed a bowl in a freshly waiting Savinelli Miele. Pipe and tobacco were made for one another! Smooth, honeyed and buttery, the "room" note filled the car as I happily motored across the north TX plains. My friend was very pleased with the aroma, commenting on it twice as we drove along to work. Smokes beautifully and I am sad to have ordered just four ounces. A larger order must go in after I finish the several pounds of various blends I have on hand including the four ounces of Scotty's Trout Stream I found just as good. If you are a fan of Lane 1Q, MacBaren Scottish and Plumcake, you'll surely like this blend.
4 out of 5
Pretty good smoke but, not
Pretty good smoke but, not as good as lanes blwb.
5 out of 5
Should have got more
i just found my everyday smoke i am truly in love. should have got more will be soon
4 out of 5
Enjoyable
I'm not a fan of aromatics but once in a while I like to indulge. For the price this was offered I couldn't resist. I found it to have a mild slightly sweet taste with a nice bag note and pleasing room note. I like it best as my first pipe of the day and perhaps a bowlful or two during the course of the day. It will never replace my regular smoke which is Granger nor will it out rank my fondness of English blends. Bottomline is it is an enjoyable smoke when I crave something different.
5 out of 5
A wonderful smoke
Smooth balanced and delightful
4 out of 5
Great smoke!
Great smoke!
5 out of 5
Butternut burley
I enjoy it for an everyday smoke. Excellent room notes!
5 out of 5
Great!
Great!
1 out of 5
What happened to the flavor!
What happened! Use to have a great butternut flaver, now it's unrecognizable. Won't be buying any of Scotty's again, because if they are not consistent on one product, they won't be on others.
5 out of 5
Great Note
I’m not a super experienced pipe smoker, but over the past seven years I have tried several different blends. This one is a family favorite because of the room note, and it has almost no tongue bite. It WAS my favorite, until I tried the Appalachian a few weeks ago. You can’t go wrong with this one, though.
4 out of 5
My apologies
I need to change my review as I think that the smell and taste of what smells like ammonia was the brand new pipe I just bought and not the tobacco itself. Tried it in an older pipe and was very pleased.
5 out of 5
5 Stars!!!!!
No tongue bite. Stays lit. Great smoke.
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley
I've been a pipe smoker for many years and prefer milder, sweeter tobacco. Butternut Burley is consistently the best I've ever smoked. One can't go wrong with it. It is a truly enjoyable smoke.
5 out of 5
Can’t ask for much more.
Buttery and smooth, wasn’t sure what that meant until I lit up the first bowl. A light sweetness shows itself amongst a lightly earthy and nutty front end. No bite and an easy after-note. This is a perfect smoke any time of day and will definitely stay in my rotation.
5 out of 5
Ready for Smoker's Heaven?
This tobacco is GREAT! With no tongue bite, lots of flavor and aroma, Scotty's "Butternut Burley" provides a truly COMFORTING smoke; like being cradled in a warm blanket on a cold day. And, there is No Fussing or Fiddling Around with this blend; your pipe will stay lit and cool right down to the bottom of the bowl! This is Definitely one to light up and enjoy. I highly recommend it.
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley-Outstanding tobacco
Outstanding burley smoke. An all day smoke that never lets you down...flavor +.
5 out of 5
Love it!
I mix it with vanilla custard and am waiting on it to get back in stock.
5 out of 5
Excellent Without The Bite!
I recently purchased the Lane Limited Light Without A Bite choice. It is truly a great smoke, gentle and full of flavor at the same time. I would highly recommend it highly!
5 out of 5
Best Burley Blend
I consider this one of the two best tobacco blends. Great in a cob.
5 out of 5
Good stuff for sure
I love butternut Burley it's my favorite. I have a few different blends. Scotty's is a good one, smooth smoke, not to wet, good tin note, room note, and taste.
5 out of 5
Outstanding Products and Service
Outstanding blend...bought a pound and liked it so much that I bought another pound. All of Scotty's blends and Russ's blends are cellar worthy. Can't say enough about P&C's customer service...always great and products are first rate. Thanks for making this hobby/way-of-life a lot of fun.
4 out of 5
Nice surprise - mellow, smooth, bekoning slight toasty sugar sweetness, with light Burley nuttiness. Kills Ready Rubbed IMO.
[Tin/bag - Nice dark sugary aroma, then it gets a little allspice or some toasty spice in there. A certain something in there that I do not like for it being a little sickening sweetness - gag reflex way down in belly just a tad. Very fluffy, small ribbon cut in with pretty much cube cut, gravity feeds into a bowl with ease. Moisture ready to smoke.] Pleasant surprise, looked like it would be an Edgeworth Ready Rubbed simple cigarette/slight nut repeat - it was not. Mellow, smooth, beckoning slight toasty sugar sweetness, with light Burley nuttiness. Beats Ready Rubbed hands down for me - by a long shot. Not going to get anything complex here, it is pretty straight forward, mellow, and simple from start to finis, with a little mild aromaticness in there that appears in many of Lane Limited's aromatics. It's like there is a veeery slight touch of 1-Q, or like you had left a bag of 1-Q sitting inside another bag of plain Burley for a day or two and some of 1-Q flavor came through the baggy, so, very light. A quite nice, mild, satisfyingly simple, mellow, smoke with consistent flavor to the end. Could be useful to tone down or add some plumage into a blend too. Smooth, and lives up to it's name with no bite, bowl maintenance, or relights needed down to fine ash. Cool burning without much heat or moisture in the bowl. ◄7/10✠Skulls►
5 out of 5
Very satisfying
Everyone enjoys the aroma and it is easy on the pallet.
5 out of 5
Very nice
As it says, smooth and no bit. Great taste.
4 out of 5
Not bad
Trout stream is still the best blend from Scotty's
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Smooth and no bite as it claims, a great evening smoke
5 out of 5
nice
I liked how this was a nice and flavorful...left a good smell when lit and i didnt get any harshness or bit when smoked..good stuff
1 out of 5
Not enough taste
Not enough taste
5 out of 5
Love
So flavorful yet so smooth. Mix it or use it as it is
5 out of 5
Please do whatever you can
Please do whatever you can to keep it in stock.
5 out of 5
SCOTTY'S BUTTERNUT BURLEY A GREAT AROMATIC
LIGHTS WELL BURNS LONGS AND HAS A VERY PLEASANT ROOM NOT AND NO TOUNG BITE. FIVE OUT OF FIVE RATING
5 out of 5
I first tried it in
I first tried it in a corn cob pipe and it was okay. I then tried it in a 12" clay pipe and it was outstanding! My wife loved the room note. There was zero tongue bite and because the smoke was cool I could get the full pleasure of the taste.
5 out of 5
Best tabaco I’ve ever tried.
Best tabaco I’ve ever tried.
2 out of 5
Nice for sweetening the room
Use it to sweeten the room but it’s not much of a smoke
5 out of 5
This stuff is great!
I don’t normally smoke aromatics, as they tend to be sugar bombs that smell good and taste bad. This is another story altogether. Great pouch aroma that translates ever so slightly to the bowl. Nice nutty burley that burns great, tastes great, and leaves little goop behind. This is hands down my favorite aro, and one of only two that I smoke regularly.
5 out of 5
BLWB
Very smooth, tasty absolutely no bite, good for an all-day smoke will definitely get more..
5 out of 5
Great everyday smoke
Mildly aromatic. Not overly sweet and good flavors from the blend. Will order more!
5 out of 5
BLWB is truly awesome.
I'm new to pipe smoking, and was introduced to this tobacco by a friend. I have to say that this is a smooth every tobacco with just enough flavor to keep you looking for the next one. Highly recommend!
5 out of 5
Great!
Very good. Smokes well. Hope it’ll be back in stock soon!
5 out of 5
Biteless
smooth & bite free love it
5 out of 5
Smooth
Smooth smoking, nice room note, no bite
5 out of 5
A fine smoking experience
An excellent, well-balanced, flavorful aromatic with well-mannered smoking characteristics. Great smoke output, burns cool, with a wonderful room note. Scotty's Butternut Burley is one of my everyday go-to aromatics.
3 out of 5
Good in small doses
What I enjoy on break at work.
4 out of 5
Very Solid "OTC" Style Blend!
These notes are my first impressions of BLWB. I’ve only had a few bowls of this, so far. I’m using it to break in my brand new Gardesana Bianca Lovat pipe (purchased at P&C, of course! I think this Lovat is going to be a good smoker). I’ve also had a large bowl in a meershaum. I suspect I’ll get to like it more over time. I agree with some of the other reviewers that there is nothing to get too excited about with this blend. But I like it. I find it to be very similar to Carter Hall, Prince Albert, Granger and the like, and I suppose that is Lane’s intention. Seems they succeeded very well. There is plenty of nuttiness here, it smokes smoothly, cooly and really doesn’t bite. The topping isn’t chocolatey. Just a gentle sweetness that is very pleasant. This blend packs easily, burns well and leaves no gunk and little moisture. Minimum re-lights. There may be some humectant applied, but if so, it seems minimal to me. BLWB does what it is supposed to do, and it does it very well. It is mild and unobtrusive, but still tasty. If you like mild, OTC, “old codger” burley blends, you can’t go wrong with BLWB. The price point is pretty good, too. It is really very decent. By the way, kudos again to P&C for incredible service! Cheers!
5 out of 5
My all day smoke.
Love this tobacco! Smooth and mild; my all day smoke.
5 out of 5
Absolutely fantastic!
Beautiful blend with overwhelmingly rich and buttery toffee nose and medium-light flavorful. 5/5 Absolutely recommend!
3 out of 5
Good Stuff
Good but not exciting when smoked on its own. Flavor runs the spectrum from A to B. However, it is a very agreeable smoke when reading or otherwise occupied when you don’t want anything complex. Where BLWB really shines is as an addition to a blend that needs to be tamed down or “diluted “ in flavor. I like to add it to certain aromatics that, while tasty, tend to be a little too sweet or syrupy. Adding BLWB can turn an overpowering blend into something quite nice, or at least smokable. It can also do wonders to help a wet blend smoke dry. I always have some on hand because it is so useful for blending.
4 out of 5
Good price
Burns good all the way down to the end of the bowl. But not as flavorful as scottys butternut burley.
5 out of 5
Fantastic burley with just the right topping
Been smoking blwb for sometime now and it never gets old. Very light with a great room note.
4 out of 5
Sweet burley
light sweet taste with mild flavor that is lightly aromatic but burley based
5 out of 5
Excellent!
I will be ordering this regularly.
5 out of 5
Pleasant surprise
This was a pleasant surprise when I open the pouch for the first time, I was greeted with this wonderful aroma. I tried it in both my brairs and cob pipes and and loved it from start to finish.
5 out of 5
A winner!
Nice and nutty. Designed for people who cannot get over the last presidential election.
5 out of 5
Great flavorful cool smoke.
Nice smooth cool smoke with a rich nutty flavor and after note.
4 out of 5
Why pay for more expensive
Why pay for more expensive tins?
5 out of 5
One of the best tobaccos
This is a very pleasant, mild aromatic tobacco
5 out of 5
Should be called butter chocolate
Starts bright and becomes chocolatey! must be some good burley, I'd like to know more about the tobaccos, toppings, flavorings used in this blend rather than just how it smokes
5 out of 5
Amazingly smooth tobacco
I've had this before, great tobacco with no tongue bite and smokes really smooth, but to me lacks nicotine. I give it 5 stars because I like to blend it with my other stronger tobaccos like G&H dark flake unscented for the absolute best smoke in the world!
4 out of 5
Good Flavor, Great Smoke
Great Smoke! Top to the bottom of the bowl Good! Not as much flavor as I thought it would but good smoke/flavor none the less. Similar flavor profile to Molto Dolce but just less flavoring! A new weekly rotation for me!
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley
This is my favorite pipe tobacco, I love the flavor and it doesn't bite my tongue . I really enjoy it.
5 out of 5
Good
Good
5 out of 5
Russ is extremely talented.
This blend, as well as Hearth Home blends is excellent. Thank You Russ, for sharing you're talent of blending high quality leaf. I as a smoker am very grateful to you.
3 out of 5
Not bad, but not great.
Not bad, but certainly not great either. Perhaps it was all the great reviews that gave me a false expectation. It's quality tobacco, and it's true there is no bite. That said there is not much flavor either. It is very close to 1q and I don't find much flavor in that either.
4 out of 5
A great little tobacco!!
I bought an ounce of this and an ounce of Lane BCA and combined them 1:1. Made a nice little mild smoke with a touch of sweetness and a nutty base. Not a master blend by any stretch, but I do like to smoke it when I'm not exactly in the mood for 1Q. More body but a little less flavor than 1Q. Honestly though, it's a great blend and BLWAB is still great on it's own. I'd recommend it absolutely for a beginner as it's very easy to pack, light, and smoke. 4/5.
5 out of 5
All Day smoke
Light, smooth, just enough nicotine. Great all day smoke
5 out of 5
Basic great tobacco
Great by itself and great to blend with any of your other tobaccos or with your own BOTR left overs.
5 out of 5
My #1 go to smoke
This blend is perfect for every day of any season. Warm creamy notes of vanilla and chocolate permeate the air and your senses. Creamy delicious smoke that tastes smooth and relaxing. The ash burns to a whisp of nothing. No bite and comepletely enjoyable. Especially with the coming holiday seasons.
5 out of 5
No bite
Nice smooth flavor and no bite! Shipping was fast
5 out of 5
Another Home Run
if you like Trout Stream...which I do... you'll like this !
5 out of 5
Great All Day Smoke
Good stuff. Burns well. Smooth, mild smoke. Good for all day.
5 out of 5
Lane B. L. Without a Bite
A smooth great smoke. Love it
5 out of 5
Best in a cob
This is one of my favorite tobaccos. Really an all day smoke.
5 out of 5
Ole Nutter Butter
Butternut Burley, I really love this blend a lot. Now. But it didn't start out that way. Admittedly, the first 2 times I smoked it (in 2 different well-seasoned pipes), I sensed it to be a bland unremarkable burley. But despite my initial disappointment, I had high hopes for this tobacco and was determined to give it all full-measure of fair trial. Call it heresy, lunacy or just plain inexplicable phenomenon, but much to my delight, the second time I smoked it in the very same 2 pipes as before, I got all the full buttery and nutty flavors I was lusting after. And evidently for me, that was no fluke. For any other pipe I own, I have to smoke this blend at least twice in it to get the proper flavor out of it. Go figure. All that oddity aside, I honestly do get nice buttery and nutty flavors washing over my tongue as I had hoped to get from it. And I occasionally detect a thin line of vanilla and honey on the side. And there is no tongue bite from it, and it burns down cleanly to a fine grey ash. The bag aroma is also buttery and nutty to my sniffer, and the room note is pleasant and mild. I doubt anyone who doesn't hate tobacco would ever complain of it. My wife likes it, and she's picky when it comes to tobacco aroma. So now I've settled-in to regularly rotating Butternut Burley with two of the Ole Shenandoah blends, Barrel No. 76 and Bootlegged. These have now become my Fave Three, with other old faves now in the less-frequent occasional opt-in lineup. So now I sometimes jokingly call it "Ole Nutter Butter". Yeah... I like those cookies too.
2 out of 5
Sorry, just didn't get that " no bite "
Sorry, just didn't get that " no bite ", smoked it 3 times in 2 different pipes. It was harsh and hot for me.
3 out of 5
Working smoke
This smoke gets better with a little age, I would like this sweeter but this is still my favorite working smoke. Also has a nice room note but still leaves a cigar afternote.
5 out of 5
Tasty
Good stuff!
3 out of 5
Butter to pass on this one
Fairly run of the mill - if your thinking your getting a butter nut taste, butter think again. Its fair at best.
5 out of 5
Excellent Tobacco
I really like this. I'm a fan of burley tobacco and this is very good. Opening the package and it reminded me of when my mother would make popcorn balls, the smell of butter and vanilla was wonderful. Upon lighting a bowl again the taste of warm vanilla and butter. This is a mild tobacco with no bite and burned to the bottom of the bowl. Very good and will order more.
4 out of 5
Excellent room note
My favorite work blend, no one complains about this one.
3 out of 5
Good to start out with.
This was my first pipe tobacco. I learned how to sip with this tobacco. The nougat smell is amazing. Upon lighting, I found out it is just pipe tobacco. The flavor is nothing special, but it is not bad. It does not bite if you smoke it right. Overall it's a good starter tobacco, and I will always keep some on hand.
5 out of 5
Loved it
A fantastic all-day smoke. Right up there with Trout Stream and Bass Pond. Excellent.
5 out of 5
A good Burley I can recommend.
SUPER burley with a great mild flavor. Perfect for mixing or smoking by itself.
5 out of 5
Plain and simple---and still just plain great.
Nothing like an old friend. I have smoked this for over 40 years, and we are still the best of friends.
4 out of 5
AS ADVERTISED
As advertised. The taste is like Lane Limited,though not exact, it is close enough. I think the cube cut makes the difference for the Lane Limited.
5 out of 5
My new favorite
One of my new favorites. Cool smoking, no tongue bite and doesn't leave a nasty tobacco taste in your mouth. Excellent tobacco for beginners but pleasant for seasoned pipe smokers as well.
5 out of 5
HIT THE SPOT
Smoke a bowl right after it arrived and boy was I pleased. Real nice burley taste, great aroma and no bite at all. Says its a fairly strong smoke but I didn't detect that. If you like burleys, you will enjoy this one.
3 out of 5
Not bad, not great either.
Best thing about it was it's mildness with no bite. Only real complaint was that I envisioned a more robust, flavorful tobacco. That's why I only by an ounce at a time when trying something new.
5 out of 5
Great all around
I loved this blend from start to finish. It is now one of my go to aromatics. No bite at all, but it is tangy! Love it!
4 out of 5
A gentle smoke with a wonderful room note
A nice light Burley blend with plenty of satisfying sweetness and a wonderful aroma.
5 out of 5
Awesomely fresh
I was pleasantly surprise by the taste and the freshness would definitely purchase again
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley
A very good smoke that stays lit easily.
5 out of 5
very mild but not much
very mild but not much aroma smell
5 out of 5
Love it!
Very tasty and can't stop smoking it. Love it!
5 out of 5
Nutty, with vanilla and honey
This is the only aromatic I smoke. It has that wonderful burley nuttiness with hints of vanilla and honey. If you like burley blends, this will be a favorite, it's nice and relaxing but not a complicated blend. Lastly and most importantly, it smells so good my wife let's me smoke it in the house. Non-smokers LOVE the room note.
4 out of 5
a good simple smoke
I enjoy a pipeful of this on occasion. And always keep some on hand.
3 out of 5
Good note, subtle but good taste
Not one of my favorites, but still a fair blend. It is a light smoke, with a suttle flavor, and a mild room note.
3 out of 5
Good note, subtle but good taste
Good room note, suttle flavor
5 out of 5
Nice package
This was bought to blend with another tobacco and it is perfect.
5 out of 5
5/5
I have to say, this was one of my favorite "on sale" blends I have tried. Came to me with a very good moisture content. Only had to light it once after the charring light. No tongue bite. A very pleasant smoke for when you are out in the woods.
2 out of 5
2.5 maybe
Not much of a taste . Kinda plain, not bad just not what I was wanting.
3 out of 5
not too bad
I bought this a few year ago, I remember it to be more flavorful, and milder, the aroma was a lot stronger. Did you change the "recipe" Overall a pleasent smoke.
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley tobacco
It has a very pleasant aroma with a nutty flavor. It's a great smoke
4 out of 5
Good Aro
Very nice all day aro with nice taste and no bite but I dont see anything so special about it like so many others do....
4 out of 5
NICE SMOOTH SMOKE
VERY GOOD QUALITY SLOW BURNING TOBACCO
2 out of 5
Not for me
Just really wasn't for me.
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley
There are not enough adjectives in the English language to describe how perfect this blend is! I spoke this like a tobacco fiend. I could smoke 4 ounces of this stuff a day if l could and would enjoy every bowl as much if not more than the previous one. The only reason l give this blend five stars (5*s) is because they have not included a choice for 6,7,8, or MORE! Thank You
5 out of 5
Scottys Buernut Burley
After trying several different blends, Scottys Butternut Burley is the blend of choice. It is a very smooth smoking tobacco with a good taste, and has no bite After smoking it has a very good lingering flavor. It is very aromatic and non-smokers compliment the way the room smells. Good Job
4 out of 5
Not a Fan of Aromatics
I'm not a fan of aromatics but occasionally like to indulge so I bought an ounce of this just to try it out. The bag note was a pleasant cross between butterscotch and maple. The tobacco was not overly moist and not as sticky as most aromatics that I've smoked. Sweet, not overpowering and no bite. Burns well. However, by the end of the ounce I pretty much had my fill of aromatics and the blend became a bit tiring.
5 out of 5
My favorite aero.
What an amazing blend. Burn quality is just as good as the taste. It is hands down my favorite aero. I add a little Prince Albert to it to give it some strength. The two compliment each other perfectly. Delicious.
5 out of 5
Scott's bulk Butternut Burly
This is NO DOUBT a GO TO SMOKE .. This blend has a Good bag or Tin Note . Moisture is Medium. Once you have it lit .. kick back relax and Enjoy this AMAZING BLEND. I Did not experience any Tounge bite and it leaves a Great Room note as well. I ordered Two ounces to try and my only regret is that I didn't order more than that.. Shawn Pa
5 out of 5
WOW!
Great taste - no bite! Room note very pleasant. Will be buying his again!
3 out of 5
IT OK BO
ITS OK BUT NOT AS GOOD AS SCOTTYS PANCAKE
5 out of 5
Butternut breakfast burley
A great tobacco for the ride to work. Very basic, yet rich in flavor. Burley and coffee go well together, and the light topping is subtle yet present, adding to the flavor profile. I really enjoy this tobacco over many OTC burleys. I don't notice any "cheap" or chemical tastes or flavors. I could smoke this every morning.
5 out of 5
Awesome
I’ll be buying more!
5 out of 5
The Best
This is the best blend to break in new pipes an to smoke all day. People around me love it and I can't find a thing wrong with it. Keep the supply going.
5 out of 5
Great Tobacco
Light, smooth, great flavor. Very happy with this tobacco and will continue to order.
5 out of 5
REALdeal
a very good blend....nice an aromatic stays lit .
5 out of 5
Love it
Even smoke nonlover wife links it! A little moist, though.
5 out of 5
The Aroma Alone Is Worth It
Best for lack of bite, nice flavor although not my favorite all time, but it always gets positive comments from others in the room.
5 out of 5
Scotty's BB
Enjoyed the smell and taste.
5 out of 5
Love it. It is the
Love it. It is the only tobacco that I have been able to stay with.
3 out of 5
It's not what I expected,
It's not what I expected, could hardly taste the flavors.
5 out of 5
Great all-around tobacco
Smooth enjoyable smoke good for anytime .
5 out of 5
Every Day Smoke
This is the one tobacco I always keep on hand.Nice nutty sweet flavor with no bite.Packs and burns well.Not expensive.I finally bought a cob and this stuff is even better in it than in some of my seasoned briars.Can`t go wrong with this.
4 out of 5
Some love sushi, some don't.
I am glad I didn't write this review after my first try at this Burley. At first, I was put off and thought it was too mild, and left me with a slight chemical taste/feel in my mouth. However, now after my third bowlful I can now that I like it. I don't love it and still feel there is a bit of that chemical feeling present. All in all I feel that is surely a nice mild smoke and can see how so many people like it. Remember, we all taste things differently. Some love sushi, some hate it.
5 out of 5
Excellent
Excellent. Very mild. No tongue bite. Great all day smoke.
3 out of 5
Good but not my go to.
Average.. Was hoping for more but didn't hit the "spot".
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley - nice
Stays light all the way to the bottom. No bite, smooth and mild smoke. Non-smokers like the aroma. Would by again.
5 out of 5
love it.
love it, will be stocking up on it.
5 out of 5
Smooth no bite fragrant
Smooth no bite fragrant
3 out of 5
High rated tobacco not great; shipping slow
Scotty's Butternut, just ok.
5 out of 5
Lane Burley-Light-Without-A-Bite
My second purchase of this product. Good quality: fresh and proper moisture. Better than similar no-bite Burley from local tobaconists. I will order from you again in the future.
5 out of 5
BLWB
Fantastic alone or mixed with RLP 6
5 out of 5
Outstanding
Very nice smoke. Great room note and flavor with no tongue bite at all.
3 out of 5
Some bite not to Pleasant
Some bite not to Pleasant smell
3 out of 5
Nice aromatic that smokes well,
Nice aromatic that smokes well, no bite, not overly sweet. Can be an all day smoke
5 out of 5
Like a dinner bell
Mouth watering aroma
5 out of 5
Not bad
Had a bowl this morning..
5 out of 5
One of the best
That's good stuff!! Loaded up my Missouri Meerschaum Mizzou corn cob pipe and enjoyed it to the end. Aromatics are light and pleasant, mellow flavor with no bite.
5 out of 5
Discovery of a historical pipe tobacco blend.
During my college days in the 60's, I smoked an Edward's Tobacco blend named "Butternut". This blend was a special one created by the Edward's shop in Atlanta, Ga. It has long ago been discontinued. Scotty's Butternut Burley is the best match that I have found. Very pleasing aroma, mild, and a pleasant room note. A welcomed discovery for my tobacco of choice, this is a quality smoking blend that I highly recommend.
5 out of 5
Relaxing, spring/summer with whiskey
Smooth medium, rolls off the tongue butternut. Relaxing, spring/summer with whiskey.
5 out of 5
Fantastic Flavor
Absolutely perfect. No bite and no aftertaste. Aroma of what you would expect from an old timey tobacco. I bought this to try and now will make this a regular purchase.
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley
First time I was given a sample of SBB I loved it. I bought a pound and a half because it's an everyday smoke. It's moist out of the bag so I take out a bowlful and let it dry for about a half hour to hour. It packs easily and lights easily as well. I've only had to give it a 2nd light only the first couple times I smoked it b/c it was new to me. Ever since, it's a one match/bowl deal. It vaguely reminds me of Capt Black but I think SBB is far better in that it as much more depth and complexity. The burly is as expected: a nutty, slightly sweet, and leather'ish component. There is no "forward" in this blend to me though ... neither the burley or the cav overpower the other. It's balanced. It starts with that burley but there is already a good cav flavor with it's smooth caramel, buttery, and even hints (to me) of jasmine. Try some. It's awesome.
5 out of 5
Happy Camper
Love this stuff, touches that niche I'm looking for where its not overpowering sweet, but still natural enough for a wonderful taste, and aroma
5 out of 5
Can't ask for more
Love the labeled bags, came fast, good quality, what else could you ask for?
5 out of 5
This Is Great Stuff!!!
This has become my favorite smoke!Taste galore,burns perfect.This is one I look forward to packing into my pipe.It usually gets back ordered fairly quick,that tells me I'm not the only one enjoying this blend.
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley
This was my first purchase of this blend and I was very happy with the product. I will definitely recommend it.
4 out of 5
Good buy
VERY good smell. Zero tongue bite. Love the cut. Just not a lot of flavor. Might just be to mild for me. Still glad I bought it.
5 out of 5
Butternut burley.
Prob my favorite of anything I've had.
5 out of 5
Don't fear this Butternut
I bought a sample of this a few months back and it was everything the reviews had claimed it to be and maybe even more. They say no tongue bite and it's true... you can puff like a dragon and it's always as smooth as can be. I added 1/3 Latakia to this and it turned into something dreams are made of. I plan on getting a pound of this for blending.
5 out of 5
OK so....
I only bought a few ounces to try after a pal & more experienced pipe smoker suggested I give some Burley a go , as I tend to enjoy Cavendish & aromatic blends most often,,so yeah it's ok for just plain smoking ,,kind of like a Camel in a bowl...but I wound up mixing up most of it in with some of the Perique and Latika ,Cavendish to make a blend of my own and it was good for mellowing out some of the powerful leaf in that mix ,I personally won't go overboard in a purchase of this except for the mixing up of a bag of my own picks,,smokes clean and down to ash if that matters to anyone ,good quality overall.
5 out of 5
Steve
Great tobacco, really enjoyable
5 out of 5
Superb Blending Base
Good, low bite tobacco especially suited for creating your own blends. I am blending in a touch of Latakia and a touch of cigar leaf. The result is a low bite, more complex flavored smoke.
5 out of 5
Solid Smoke
This lived up to the hype and is an excellent tobacco. Smooth and flavorful. Smokes cool. Now a regular in my rotation and one of my favorites.
4 out of 5
Simple burley
If your looking for complex flavors, look somewhere else. It's an easy lighting no frills tobacco. Reminds me of prince albert but a little less sweet. If simple works for you, and sometimes that just what I want go for it.
5 out of 5
Perfect In a Cob
Perfect In a Cob and highly recommend.
5 out of 5
Smooth, soothing, satisfying, and enjoyable.
When I received the package of Scotty's Butternut Blend I was skeptial because I didn't get the aroma from the bag I expected. However after lighting up and a few puffs, I was delightfully pleased, the longer I smoke the better it got! This stuff is great! It burns evenly, doesn't bite your tounge, and it is very satisfying. Has a pleasing room note, which is very important these days...... I'll be ordering more of this blend for sure and certain.
4 out of 5
Burley Light Without Bite
The name says it all. Excellant flavor and aroma. Reminds me of a tobacco I smoked for years before it was discontinued- Paul Bunyan Biteless Burley.
5 out of 5
Butternut
I have been smoking a pipe for 45 years. This blend is now one of my standards. Everyone likes the room note. I like the taste.
5 out of 5
Tasty is the name of the game.
Fills the palate. An experience all it's own.
4 out of 5
Loved the price and variety
Will continue to try puppe tobacco samples until I fingers the holy grail i am in search of
5 out of 5
A delightfully uncomplicated smoke
I had such a great experience with Trout Stream that I decided to try another Scotty's blend. Butternut Burley is the one I selected as a follow up. This is a wonderful aromatic that has a warm, comfortable room note. Tastes great because the topping doesn't mask the flavors of the underlying tobacco components. Burns great, easy to light and no tongue bite. If you are a beginning your journey with the pipe, Scotty's blends would be a great place to start...this one in particular. And if you've been around a while, there's a great deal here to appreciate from time to time. Try it out and post a review to share your opinion.
5 out of 5
BLWB
BLWB is a very must have. It is very lightly cased with 1Q favoring. It could almost pass as non aromatic. It has perfect mechanics, packs and smokes easily and never bites. Smokes cool and flavorful with an uncomplicated nutty flavor. This would be a great tobacco for a beginner.
5 out of 5
My new regular!
Very good smoke! I can smoke this blend all day long and the wife loves the aroma too! One of my new favorites!
5 out of 5
Smooooooth!
Purchased as a gift for my 30 year old son. Reports it's a very enjoyable smoke. I say shipping was fast.
5 out of 5
Smooth w/no bite.
This is a mild smoke with an awesome taste and smell.
5 out of 5
very good. one of my
very good. one of my favorites
5 out of 5
nice smooth tobacco
Excellent smokw without bite.
5 out of 5
Butternut Burley
Buttery smooth and delicious!
5 out of 5
Great smoke!
Just a great, all day smoke. I will be ordering more of this. One of my 3 favorites.
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Blend
This blend has become one of my all-time favorites. There's a very satisfying flavor with no tongue bite. I would recommend this blend to all of my fellow pipe smokers. In my opinion it certainly deserves a five-star rating!
5 out of 5
A good mixer
Mixed with Burley and Black and McClelland 600 it works great.
5 out of 5
No bite and wife approved as far as the aroma.
Very light jn flavor,no bite, and totally wife approved.
5 out of 5
great taste
Great tasting tobacco. Excellent price. going to do the sample package.
5 out of 5
BLWB Tobacco
Like the way it smokes but a coarser cut would be better.
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley bulk - Good Smoke
Butternut Burley - Good smoke - great for all day - burns a clean ash - pleasant aroma.
5 out of 5
services
Your organization offers great products at very reasonable prices.Thanks
5 out of 5
Excellent tobacco
Excellent tobacco. Great by it self or blended. Amazing addition to a LOT of other blends....
5 out of 5
Great taste
smooth and tasty. The Aroma really makes the whole block more enjoyable.
5 out of 5
scottys butternut burley
my go to smoke. nice and mellow
5 out of 5
Scotty's Butternut Burley is a Hoe Run
Very smooth with no bite. Nothing needs to be added to this blend. Very nice tobacco taste and great room note. Butternut Burley doesn't leave any ghost flavors in you pipe. I'll be getting more of this when my supply runs out.
5 out of 5
New pipe smoker
I'm a new pipe smoker, found this site and decided to try several different tobaccos. One of which is Scotty's Butternut Burley. Great smoke, love the flavor and the mildness.
5 out of 5
Always good tobacco
I get this all the time. It's a good smoke with consistent quality
5 out of 5
Jon Patterson. Recovering cigarette addict.
Found it both satisfying and far smoother than I expected. As nice at the bottom of the bowl as when I first light up. Best of all, I can smoke it in the house. No more trips outside in foul weather.
5 out of 5
Scottie's Butternut Burley
I have been a pipe smoker for about 45 yrs and chain smoke my pipes. I have been smoking BB for about 10 yrs now. BB is the only tobacco I have found that I can smoke all day with little or no bite. I really like it.
4 out of 5
Not quite but almost
You're absolutely right, this is the mildest pipe tobacco you have sold. The flavor and aroma are a bit on the mild side, and I've had one tobacco which had all the flavor, aroma, and mildness -- and the company went out of business 2 years ago. So the search for the perfect (available) tobacco continues, but this is nice stuff.
CLICK HERE to learn how to get FREE SHIPPING on your entire order!