If you find yourself searching for a beach and a warm breeze, here at P&C we can help with that with the Caribbean Clash. Two pipe tobaccos that will have you tasting the rum flavors in no time. Going head to head are Cornell & Diehl's Jamaican Rum, a traditional Cavendish base blend that is topped with a zesty splash of rum flavor, and Sutliff's Spiced Rum, a pipe blend that has exotic spice with a bit of vanilla combined with the rum flavor mixed with Burley and black Cavendish. Now we need to call on our P&C Faithful to help determine which is the Caribbean Clash battle leader. At this time you can purchase both tobaccos at a low price and be able to smoke them side by side. Once you have tried them, come back and leave your review and tell us who the clear winner should be.
I have only tried this Spiced Rum twice so far. I liked the 2nd bowl better than the first. Many of the other rums I like and this one could grow on me. One of my favorites is buttered rum by several makers(several sellers are excellent) and it took me 4 or 5 bowls for me to really like them. So I will have to wait and see but it was not bad to begin with so it may grow on me.
5 out of 5
FANTASTIC! wife loves the room
Sep 12, 2021
FANTASTIC! wife loves the room note, mild smoke, not wet and gloppy, burns well for an aromatic. Will buy again and again.
5 out of 5
Good product at a good
Jun 05, 2021
Good product at a good price!!
5 out of 5
Great aromatic at a fantastic price!
May 14, 2021
It came very wet, which is great, if your want in your face type aromatic. The flavor is definitely what I was wanting. Notes of rum, spices and a bit of bakery. Take your time and enjoy
5 out of 5
Great
Apr 22, 2021
Didnt actually get to try any of this, got it for my stepdad. He seems to really enjoy it.
5 out of 5
A nice smoke...mild with good
Feb 20, 2021
A nice smoke...mild with good flavor finish
5 out of 5
best rum aromatic
Jan 23, 2021
best rum bulk aromatic to date for me.
5 out of 5
This is my favorite tobacco
Dec 24, 2020
This is my favorite tobacco blend. Always a full flavored smoke. No tongue bite. Wonderful aroma and room note.
5 out of 5
Love it
Nov 24, 2020
Love it
5 out of 5
The Best
Aug 30, 2020
A great aromatic and an all day smoke. I don't leave home without it.
5 out of 5
Love it
Aug 16, 2020
A great smoke in every way! It’s one of my top 5 tobaccos. I sometimes mix it half and half with Barbados plantation.
5 out of 5
It’s my favorite Tobacco don’t
Mar 30, 2020
It’s my favorite Tobacco don’t stop selling it it’s a winner!
3 out of 5
Expected better
Feb 01, 2020
Overly sweet and rummy.
3 out of 5
ok
Dec 01, 2019
ok...not getting a lot of spice , but it could just be my taste.
5 out of 5
Great tobacco
Nov 22, 2019
Been smoking this for several years. Very mild and good smell. People sit next to me just to smell tobacco.
4 out of 5
Great smell and flavor.
Nov 14, 2019
Great smell and flavor.
5 out of 5
My favorite all-day smoke
Sep 08, 2019
This is mild but flavorful with a great aroma. Currently my favorite all-day tobacco. Great with a cup of coffee in the morning all the way to scotch in the evening.
5 out of 5
Sutliff Spiced Rum
May 15, 2019
I hope you continue to sell this because it is one of our best sellers.
4 out of 5
Sutliff Spiced Rum
May 08, 2019
Thought I would try this because I have smoked Lane's Butternut Rum...The flavor wasn't that bad, was rather moist and had to let it try out for a couple of days..However, after smoking a pound I am returning to my favorite's Lane Butternut Rum and Hazelnut....
4 out of 5
Sutliff Spiced Rum
May 04, 2019
Good taste and room note, wished it had a bit more Rum taste to it.
4 out of 5
One of the best rum
Mar 13, 2019
One of the best rum flavored bulks out there. If you like rum, this one is for you. It burns clean, smoked in a cob or a briar.
5 out of 5
One of my absolute favorites
Mar 02, 2019
It’s a wet burning tobacco and I prefer it in a filtered pipe but the flavor and richness is wonderful. It’s just sweet enough to satisfy and goes perfectly with my favorite toffee coffee. Really quite a relaxing experience enjoying a bowl of this flavor and a cup of coffee in the morning.
5 out of 5
WOW
Jan 08, 2019
This stuff it TASTSY and smells great.
5 out of 5
Spiced rum
Sep 24, 2018
I’ve been smoking your product for 10 years. Spiced rum is by far the best tabacco ever
5 out of 5
i love it
Sep 20, 2018
very smooth
5 out of 5
JUST AS ADVERTISED
Aug 18, 2018
Delightful, and just as most have described. The ribbon cut needed just a little drying first, but really delivered on flavor, without any bite. I had tried Pumpkin Spice before this, which is similar. However, the Spiced Rum seems a bit more mellow and well behaved. You'll make friends with this one, and yet the wonderful aroma doesn't completely hide the tobacco taste, although it's well sublimated. And, no chemical taste, either. Definitely a keeper, and I expect that it's going to mix very will with some of my milder Virginia (less aromatic) blends, adding just hint of sweetness to them, while allowing more tobacco taste to filter through.
5 out of 5
Smooth
May 30, 2018
Smooth smoke with a good room note. Burns easy with little to no bite.
5 out of 5
Love It
May 29, 2018
Was not sure when I ordered it but thought I’d give it a try. I was more than pleasantly surprised!! I really love this blend and it has become one of my favorites!! Smooth, with a great room note.
5 out of 5
Excellent
May 14, 2018
The spiced rum flavor was very smooth and mild, not to mention it’s smelled wonderful. Will definitely be ordering it again.
5 out of 5
Tasty smooth
Apr 09, 2018
The smell of the straight tobacco congers thoughts of dark buttery rum, mocha and honey. The slow smoking burn is rich and room note off the hook!
4 out of 5
A good change.
Feb 20, 2018
I usually smoke a blend with a very high % of black Cavendish & very strong. I tried this for a change & found it to be pleasant. I would have given it a 5 star rating if it was in the style of tobacco I usually smoke. I would recommend it to folks who like a mild blend with a rum topping.
3 out of 5
I like the Buttered Rum much better.
Feb 04, 2018
I enjoyed it, but not as much as the Sutliff Buttered Rum .
4 out of 5
Good Stuff
Sep 24, 2017
Dark rum flavor & more. You may or may not want to dry this out a little, I like it as it is. It smokes cool and doesn't leave lots of goop in the pipe. I love the tastes I get when smoked slowly, vanilla, rum, spiced cake, raisin, & nuts. Not a lot of nicotine and no tongue burn. If you're an aromatic smoker, this is worth your time to try it.
3 out of 5
MILD, SMOOTH, But Somewhat BLAND😦!
Sep 23, 2017
It Has NO Tongue BITE That I Can DETECT😉👍! It Simply NEEDS Something ELSE To Add A FOUNDATION To It😳! Maybe Some CHERRY Or GRAPE🍇! Will I Buy Any MORE🤔🙄? PROBABLY😃!
5 out of 5
A Christmasy Eggnog Holiday in your pipe!
Sep 18, 2017
My favorite aromatic, and i've tried them all!! No seriously.. look up user Young Piper on tobaccoreviews.com Reminds me of Christmas with vanilla, nutmeg, eggnog and cookies. Everyone loves the aroma. When it first arrives, you MUST either dry out for a couple days OR put in the oven on a baking pan at 200 degrees for 10 minutes. I mix this with Captain Black Royal bulk, 3/4 Spiced Rum to 1/4 Royal. What a treat!
5 out of 5
Simply wonderful
Sep 05, 2017
Great taste and aroma with no bite. Will buy again
4 out of 5
A light smoke
Aug 22, 2017
Very nice tobacco, soft on the pallet. Smells fantastic. Overall a good quality smoke. Not much nicotine. Burns nicely in the bowl, not too hot. I would buy this again, without hesitation. Let it set and age, you won't be disappointed. Just a wonderful light smoke.
5 out of 5
Most Smoked Blend
Jul 08, 2017
My favorite blend is Sutliff's Barbados Rum which I save for vacation time! This blend is what I smoke most days the rum flavor lasts all the way to the bottom of the bowl.
5 out of 5
Very enjoyable and tasty smoke. My best ever.
May 30, 2017
Very enjoyable pipe tobacco. Smooth, lightly aromatic without any bite. I enjoy smoking this tobacco for a lot longer than any other tobacco that I have tried cause its tasty and smooth, it does not have any harsh after effects.
My only concern is that my tobacco pouch came very moist, had to leave the bag open for days to normalize and dry a bit so I could enjoy smoking it without lighting it several times cause it used to go out quickly. P&C should not moisten it so excessively.
5 out of 5
Really like this one
Jan 15, 2017
Smoke was smooth with nice aroma would buy this one again.
5 out of 5
Truly Great!
Dec 19, 2016
Amazing flavor! I never had to relight it, and it makes my morning coffee taste better.
5 out of 5
Amazing
Dec 07, 2016
Awesome smoke! In my top three! Smokes, and tastes great, smooth with no bite! Highly recommended!
5 out of 5
Sutliff Spiced Rum, A+++
Oct 07, 2016
Really like this one, it's one of my top 3 go to blends. Very smooth and cool smoke with excellent taste and aroma. Every time I smoke it someone comments on how nice the room note is. Definitely worth a try.
5 out of 5
Great flavor no bite.
Sep 04, 2016
Top all day smokes.
5 out of 5
I Was`t Expecting This.......
Aug 26, 2016
First off, i am a " English Pipe Smoker " andI was`t going to get this tobacco cause it was`t my cup of tea. I was going to get another " Fall month pipe tobacco ". I hate just ordering one tobacco for a sample and the postage. Now that i did. Man i am very much loving this Spiced Rum. I do not know why this is called SPICED, its not spiced with any flavoring like coconut or any other rum that i have every had in a smoke or drink. But I like this its smooth, no bite and very easy on the ballet. I get a lot of compliments on the room note. Its sure is a morning till bedtime smoke.
5 out of 5
LOVE IT
Aug 22, 2016
GREAT STUFF
5 out of 5
NO COMPLAINT
Jun 25, 2016
I have tried many aromatic tobaccos, although heavy English are my favorite. This will be one I will reorder in lager amounts in the future. It is a crowd pleasing, room note with many compliments.
5 out of 5
John's review
May 30, 2016
Great smoke! Plenty of flavor and great aroma!
5 out of 5
Perfect
Apr 19, 2016
This has been my favorite Sutliff. Very mild and pleasant after taste.
5 out of 5
very good, but slightly to mellow.
Apr 07, 2016
I am a beginner pipe enthusiast, and have only tried a handful of tobaccos. The spiced rum is one of my favorites so far, because it smokes very smooth, and has a good flavor, but is a little to mellow for my tastes. My friends also like the aroma, which is a plus. I give this product 4.5 stars.
5 out of 5
my first favorite
Apr 05, 2016
Im a beginner pipe enthusiast, and so far this seems to be my favorite tobacco. Ive tried several brands and blends, but i truly enjoy this one the best. Maybe my opinion will change as I continue to acquire new tastes, but for now I'm happy :)
By providing my email address, I agree to receive special offers by email from Pipes and Cigars.
No purchase necessary. Click here for contest rules.
Click here for contest winners.
Privacy Policy.
Sign Up for Email Specials
