Georgia Beatdown

I loved them both, sutlif being darker and slightly wetter smoke, mixed together made for an amazing smoke!

Amazing flavor my favorite smoke so far. Burns a little slow high moisture to mine.

Best peaches and creme. The creme caramelizes and that's a win.

I love both these tobaccos but I must say as a Georgia boy, I’m go with the Sutliff peach cobbler. The flavor is amazing and the aromatics are real nice. Don’t get me wrong Stokkebye has done great with their peaches and cream. Nice easy smoke with a subtle hint of peaches that just makes me happy after a long day. I highly suggest getting this sample and see which one is your favorite because you won’t regret it, I will buy more in the future for sure.

The best aromatic that I have smoked

Overall one of my favorites, summer flavors , refreshing taste

Not that great was a bit dissapointed

Better than expected, a good burn and nice room note.

Smoking a pleasant and easy to enjoy after a new beer

Great smoke great room and stay lit good

bit me and not that great of flavor

Nice blend ready to smoke not to dry or wet. Not to crazy on the aromatic side does have that nice peach smell upfront. Smooth smoke as well

Tasty the moist tobacco made it a slow burn that’s what I liked.

Nice burn and flavorful. Very good if you like peach.

Not my cup of tea

Delicious!

I bought this for the peaches and cream….it was basically the same price…and I got the stokkebye as a bonus…..I’ve had a bowl of each, I prefer the peaches and cream…the stokkebye had a vegetal aftertaste…oh, well I’ll age it and try it in a few months

Great smelling strong aroma, however the taste is very minimal.

Enjoyable

Little to no bite. Taste was mild. Lite room note.

It is a Strong Aromatic and Moist Tabacco.

Although, both are great tobaccos with great flavor. Of the two, the peach cobbler is the best for me, it's a smooth and sweet tobacco, which is what I like.

Oh this aromatics a great blend. Great fruit room notes. Good cool smoke.

Smooth!

Delicious

tasty

Very nice room note and blends well with vanilla.

awesome flavor & aroma for me !!! I get a lot of positive comments from other smokers at the pipe & cigar store all of the time with it , I only smoke meerschaums custom built to my specs !!!

Such pleasant smoke. One of my "go to" blends. Sweet peachy that tastes like it smells and leaves the room smelling of peachy goodness. Also leaves a sweet smell to my pipe after the smoke. Burns even, very little bite that only happens if you get puffing hard. The peachy taste does die out before the bowl is done, but the sweetness stays til the end. I usually let it air out about a half hour before packing the bowl. Definately a winner for me.

Great aroma, very cool smoking, and the flavor was really good, it may be my new favorite

The smell is once again perfect. But this tobacco is best enjoyed blended in with darker or chocolate flavored tobaccos.

Bought a pound of this to get the jar and fill out my order. Was I ever surprised by how good this is. The blend aroma is so nice my wife wants it for potpourri. It burns light, with a pleasant aroma and seems to not give me any tongue bite, and I smoke a pipe hot. Absolutely one of the best buys I have made.

It had a delicious aroma but a bite to equal it.

Amazing smell and very fresh.

Great Smoke Smells Awesome

One of the best smelling blends. Great aroma which fills the room.

Great all around

Great aroma and smoke.

Burns fairly even pleasant smell and taste

Burns fairly even, smells wonderful and tastes pleasant

My favorite. The room note brings the air alive. Fun to smoke. A must have.

Smooth and mild

Got in a face off package. While the competitor had a tad bit more peach flavor, the peaches & creme had less bite and a smooth ending.

Not as peachy as i expected a good smoke though and no one complained about the smell.

I have combined these two for a long time and it makes a very good and flavorful smoke.

Good blend, delicious taste, decent room notes

no bite. very plaesent aroma smells great while smoking very good after ice cream tops it off.

Great tobacco. Use it as a sweetener with my Sutliff Cavendish.

Would recommend this one for flavor good smoke with little bite

A mild flavor and aroma. The mix seemed to be a decent quality. Although it is decent, I won't purchase again. Shipping and service was good.

I've been smoking Peachs&Cream for years. It is a constant part of my aromatic rotation. The ribbons are consistent with browns and blacks in nice proportions. It requires no drying time a d packs and lights well right out of the bag. My wife is not a fan of the smell of pipe tobacco, but she loves the smell of P&C. You really get the sensation of eating a peach. It has never let me down

Great quality and excellent flavor

Good stuff

A longtime favorite

Great options fast delivery

Great aroma, smooth smoking very pleasant tobacco. Now my new favorite.

Not bad, weak peach flavor, but a little tongue bite.

Great

It was a lot of fun to try this one. Stokkebye easily won in my opinon. It not only won, but it became my instant favorite. It smokes incredibly and completely with an excellent smell and flavor down to the last. I've taken to aging it, and am excited for the results.

Really quite tasty this one. A little young and wet, but I can tell that once matured, this will provide an excellent smoke. Not overbearing in flavor, and just the right amount of peach notes. Finishes smooth and sweet.

Smooth smoking, light on the palate, no bite. Very cool. I like it best in an oom paul.

The flavor was smooth and nice across the tongue. The aroma I hope to be a little more stronger. The room note all in all was good.

The best for the price

Both blends are smooth and great tasting as well as have an amazing room note. After several bowls of each in a corn cob pipe Stokkebye Peaches & Cream was sweeter, but Sutliff Peach Cobbler was rich in flavor and went down smooth even with me smoking it fast.

Smooth smoking and very aromatic. Great for an evening relaxing with a cold dark ale.

Very good. Smooth....

Sutliff Peach Cobbler is SUPERB. I just started smoking Vanilla Custard, and I thought, there's nothing better. But this Peach Cobbler is incredibly rich and smooth.

One of my favorite aromatics

Love this stuff. It smells and tastes just like it says. I'm still new to the tobacco world but the cut I guess is just fine.

Like the taste and smell wonderful

Outstanding! The flavor is awesome and the room note is great! Perfect cut that burns good.A very well balanced blend!

Great quality, slow burn, great taste, grandpa loves the quality and will be ordering more

Amazing

I really love this blend. It's a regular in my rotation

Mild smoke no bite.

Always on time and fresh on my favorite choices of PS

Very nice smoke. Easy burn with pleasant aroma. I like this one.

Great aroma and room note. The blend is superior to the peach brandy I smoked back in the 60's. The flavor is not overpowering and I enjoy it for a change from my normal tobaccos.

Wow. Just Wow. Immediate new favorite. I normally get the royal captain black, this is my new go to. I can't put it down

Best mix

It's strong aroma needs to be toned down. Which is why I blend it half and half with mellow peach.

Very good smoke, but I enjoyed Peter Stokkebye 303 a little better.

Great Peach Smell out of jar. Nice Mild Mellow smoke. Very enjoyable Smoke!

Smooth and no bite and nice aroma !

Peach cobbler is my favorite Sutliff Tobacco

Peter Stokkebye Peaches & Cream is my number one tobacco, I smoke probably 5+ bowls a day, I have others but this one I reaching for everytime I fill one of my pipes,Everyboby love the smell and so do I and the taste ,Peaches & Cream is a WIN ,WIN for me

Not too strong of peach cobbler flavor & no bite or strong after taste

I really enjoyed the great service I received. Your site and employees are terrific! I plan to continue buying your products in the future. Thank you. Robert Gillespy

It's a peach

I enjoy it

Loved it

not much of a aromatic but has a great flavor

It was alright, but Sutliff has alot better. I couldn't really detect a peach flavor while smoking

The peach really isn't there. Some sweetness, very moist, uneven cut. Smokes wet with many re-lites and has more tongue bite than I usually get as a smoke sipper. I'll finish the bag, but I won't be buying this particular blend again. There a plenty better peach tobaccos out there.

TOTALLY AWESOME!!!!

Smooth tobacco

Flavor was fantastic, but very moist blend.

Very happy with my choice to get this the aromatic of the is very soothing make you think of the peach cobbler or peach pie baking in the oven

My absolute favorite

Great flavor! Can really taste peaches!

Peach cobbler has a nice flavor...I enjoy smoking it....very euphoric!

Smokes well. Very light peach flavor, personally would have preferred more intense peach tones to mix.

I like it.

Could have a bit more peach ...

no stem bite with this blend .

Mild and slightly sweet. Great aroma

A little too sweet!

Awesome tobacco,,,and get complements on the enjoyable fragrance,,they tell me it's a great smell and not over powering,,,thanks all,,great job on the freshness always on the product,,,j

I asked P&C for a recommendation for a mild smoke. This was their second recommendation. As stated, an easy nose, not harsh at all. Slight and I mean slight bite. But I’ve learned you get that in any “flavored “ tobacco. As I requested it’s a mild tobacco good for light working and taking a frequent break.

I have tried 3 oz of Peter Stokkebye 303 Peaches and Crème and 3 oz of Newminster 303 Creamy Peaches. By far and away Newminster 303 is better in my view. I consistently got some floral notes in the PS 303 which did not go well with the peach flavor. I love fruity aromatics and didn't care for the flowers that came with this one. Newminster 303 rendered a solid, creamy peach taste that rolled over my tongue like a shot of coffee creamer. I can't tell if it is the topping or one of the underlying tobaccos that threw me off on this one. It was a worthwhile test but I will go back to the Newminster 303 for my next fix of creamy peaches. I gave this a 3/5 and gave the Newminster 303 a 4/5.

I LOVE this tobacee! Its got an ACTUAL noticeable flavor of what the name reads! Well.... i dont know about the cobbler part, but it has a definite peach taste! I get soo frustrated and im so bitter at tobaccos not tasting like their titles . But this one does have a peach flavor no doubt. I had a few pinches of lane BCA and i mixed the rest of the BCA and an equal amount of the peach cobbler and it, cut it up with scissors (as i do lately to try to find ways to make my smoke burn more even and friggin consistent) packed it in a corn cobber, and it tastes tremendous! its a perfect mixture! id call it peaches n cream for sure! its a great flavor from sutand good for mixin!

Truly delicious with no tongue bit

This was the aromatic blind I fejj in love with back in collage. Im back ib the hobby again and will keep this blind in my humidor on the ready.

Great flavor, cool burning, my new favorite

nice smooth all day type of smoke.

The amazing sweet flavor of peaches and a wonderful moist tobacco

By far the best peach tobacco. I tried it because I was seeking a replacement for McClelland fruity tobaccos. It tastes VERY like eating peach pie, including the crust and spices. This is one of my new go-to blends.

Very pleasing room note love the taste a bit on the wet side but not a big deal set enough out for a bowl then pack it later.

Wonderful, nice flavor and very good burn. Every once in awhile we mix a little Sutliff mint with it. We will keep buying!

Very noticeable and smooth peach flavor. Very nice smoke

good flavor i like

Amazingly soft sweetness. Doesnt over power. A bit on the wet side so put it in your humidor to settle before smoking

Wonderful peach flavor with both of these tobaccos I don't think I could pick one over the other they both are satisfying with a great peach aroma too.

I’m not always looking for a serious aro, but this one is pleasant, cool burning, great room note, bite free, and relaxing. It’s dessert. That’s what it is. Dessert any time of the day or night.

This is one of my favorites! Nice smoke and I constantly get people commenting on how nice it smells.

I've tried many peach tobacco blends lately so that I could narrow them down to one I could have on hand at all times. This is definitely it.

Can't really decide been smoking them bowls for about 4 days I smoke probably two to three bowls a day and in the evening I prefer the peach cobbler in the morning I prefer the peaches and cream they're both outstanding

I mixed with vanilla tobacco and great aroma ... try it

Tin note is of rich peach smell, taste is present. The peach flavor is strong enough to detect, yet not overwhelming or chemical. Bread notes come through periodically during smoke. Mine came a bit moist and needed drying time. Retrohale helps bring the peach flavor forward. Peach flavor is reminiscent of a peach tea. Enjoyable smoke worth trying, will be ordering more. Pipe used: MM Country Gentlemen Bent bit.

I bought this twice, smooth and great tasting. Pleasant room note. I like it.

Just OK. Nice and moist, faint peach smell

Not a bad buy! Upon opening package you smell the peachy aroma and smokes smoothly.

A very nice mellow smoke, I get the peaches I do miss the taste of crème. Being there but it is smooth. I start the day off with it for now. And do plan to order more I would recommend it to be in anyone rotation. It makes for a good change.

Very smooth with a great flavor. It’s on top of my list

I have tried many pipe tobaccos and this is my favorite! It is sweet and mellow and very cool to smoke.

Peach Cobbler is the best

This was the first time I tried a peach flavored tobacco, I found it to be a pleasant smooth smoke very easy on the tongle and the room note was approved by my wife.

Never had any pipe tobacco that was peach flavored but it was a pleasant blend. It smokes smooth and it was easy on the tongue. The room note was pleasant and my wife approved it.

Great taste, and a very pleasant aroma. I am only giving this 4 stars just for the fact that it doesn't want to burn well all the time. But otherwise a very pleasant, tasteful smoke. I definitely recommend it.

Every thing I expected. I will buy it again.

Amazing flavor and moist and burns well aromatic as it should be

Starts out veryy nice but, no pun intended, the "peach" burns off. Does not last long enough for me.

this is a very delightful mixture great room note very mild .smokes dry a real crowed pleases taste is like fresh peaches so far aroma stays great no fading this is a real winner! thanks Robert.

It's an alright tobacco, but I prefer the Peaches & Cream.

a nice peach blend

I opened this bag and found it immediately delicious. Delightful, creamy flavor and room note a-plenty. I bought a glass jar just for this one, as I am going to be placing an order for a pound here shortly.

Although I purchased a few oz on a whim, I found this delicious and among my best picks so far from P&T. Plenty of flavor and aroma. To my palate, peach is the strong player, but I also got apple and a hint of tree nuts in my pouch. A definite reorder for me. I love Sutliff aromatics and this one did not disappoint.

one of the best I've smoked, great flavor, and very aromatic, a great all day smoke

This is my favorite smoke it’s aroma is amazing and the taste is wonderful

I really enjoyed this one. It smokes very well with no tongue bite, stays lit well and has a very sweet taste like candied peaches. The room note is remarkable, in that, it smells exactly like someone baking peach cobbler in a dutch oven. If you are a fan of aromatics like me, I highly suggest picking this one up.

Tobacco is really moist and hard to keep lit, even after 4 days leaving the lid off the canister. Not empressedwith this brand.

Sometimes you just love something and simply do not care what others might say. Sutliff's Peach Cobbler fits that description perfectly for my self. It hits my "oh, yeah" zone with reckless abandon. Be forewarned as it is rather wet when it arrives, so be sure to let it dry out a bit before igniting. The room note even had a few folks I know, whom despise tobacco and tobacco smell in all forms, asking permission to sample my pipe and rummage their snout throughout my tobacco pouch. (Vanilla Custard was the only other tobacco that had a similar affect upon those same haters). I truly love non-aromatics more, but if you're looking for a smoke that might make you nostalgic for simpler times, is a great all-day smoke, & will leave others around you pleased with your "habit," then definitely give this a try. One spot of bother to note: if you're hoping that the peach flavor will last throughout the whole bowl, you might be disappointed. It tends to evaporate in the 4th quarter. (Much like some of our favorite sport teams).

Best tasting pipe tobacco with no bite

A very nice smoke. Smells good and tastes good. A little on the moist side though. A good morning coffee pipe load will get you on your way. I will order more!

Good!

Stokkebye peaches is a delightful blend, for smoking alone or blending. It is dark in appearance but not too dark, light and refreshing to smoke and fragrant as well as delicious. Should be dried for an hour before lighting. Mixes well with vanilla and cherry.

Well, the title speaks for itself, really. The Peter Stockebye Norwegian is really nice, and is easily my favorite... Its smooth and easy burning without too much bite.

That's a wonderful peachy cream flavor it's not harsh smokes good to the end.

Bought as replacement for McClelland’s "Georgian Cream” (my everyday smoke for years). It fits the bill quite well! Still miss McClelland though.

Tastes like smoking peach yogurt. Weird aftertaste.

Good quality tobacco that smells great in the pouch and while smoking

It tastes good. Just a little on the moist side. Had to let it do some drying for about three weeks before I could enjoy smoking it. Good tobacco

Reminds me a bit of artificial peach actually. Not bad, it smoked alright and was over-all pleasant.

Even though there are only slight differences between the two blends that difference is enough to pick a hands down winner. The 303 has a realistic, well rounded flavor that not only smokes well by itself, but can be easily blended with a mellow Cavendish or a Perique. This will be part of my blending experience for my years to come.

Has sweet note that goes well after a nice dinner and a fine whisky. Highly recommend

Peach Cobbler - a tobacco I tried on a whim. Guess I was hungry :) But simply amazed at the favor and smoothness of this smoke. Peach notes for sure and another note I can't describe but I really like

Sutliff's Peach Cobbler tobacco is like having dessert in a pipe. It smokes mild with no tongue bite and tastes like peaches and vanilla throughout the whole smoke. A friend came over one night while I was smoking this and asked "who's cooking peaches?" "I'm smoking them in my pipe" I replied. He laughed and asked " Was it hard getting peaches in that pipe?" "Nope, once the peach pit is removed, it's quite easy!" I puffed back.

Another very good blend from Sutliff. Smooth and pleasant.

Smooth and very enjoyable smoke,just hard to get at times.Apparently a very good smoke

My Favorite

Sutliff is my go to aromatic brand. This is a good smoke with lots of peach. Great flavor and room note.

Great flavor this became my favorite as soon as I tried it

This is a mild pleasant tobacco that my wife loves to smell in the house.

I ordered 5 Peter Stokkebye blends. This was the only one I liked. It was average. I'm rating it 3 stars. Another blender can take peaches and creme and make it great. Not this one. I'll keep an eye out for another blender.

This is one of my four stable balk mixes. I find it mild, with a good room note and no bite. Good Service from P &C with all my purchases.

I really like Sutliff Peach Cobbler. It's very aromatic and the off and on peach taste is fantastic. First bowl lasted 1 hour and only had to relight twice. To me it is very mild and had no tounge bite. The wife loves the smell. This will be in my rotation for as long as I can get it.

An enjoyable all day smoke with a pleasant, slightly sweet, fruity flavor and no tongue bite. The rich tobacco taste comes through, which I like, though I prefer a slightly stronger flavor intensity.

I have been getting this for about a year I like the taste

More creme than peach, but still enjoyable for a mild blend.

Great in Bag aroma- pre smoke Slightly disappointed in room note and flavor, others couldn't detect peaches and cream, wasn't offensive just no real opinion from the group of non-smokers in the area on it. Was fairly easy to keep lit and was a cool smoke. Peaches and creme flavor was there but wasn't strong. Overall, definitely worth a try, especially for those who like subtle flavor notes

just tried it last night. beyond incredible

Sutliff has aromatics nailed. This tastes exactly like it smells.

Very Good flavor will buy again

Reminds me of the oatmeal we ate growing up. Not over powering taste. Wonderful room notes. Smooth finish

Dont really know what to review,, it doesnt taste like peach cobbler but it isnt a bad taste either, Tobacco is sticky and last a long time in my cheap corn cob pipes. I got alot of tobacco for my money ( IMO) and probably the size of a stuffed snack ziplock although it comes in a sandwish size ziplock half full..

This is about to ne reordered in bulk. Keep reaching for it over my other blends. Just smokes so good rolled up. Perfect texture, flavor and burns smooth as can be. This is what I crave after a long day of work.

This is my second purchase of this product. What a pleasant smoke and room note. So pleasant and relaxing at the end of the day. Smooth til the end of the bowl. Packs well. It will probably be my regular.

First few bowls were amazing and had a great taste and very nice smell with little tounge bite and also burned very nice and even. Halfway through the bag the taste and smell just disappeared.

Peach Cobbler is sure to be a hit in your pipe humidor or roll, and whatever room you smoke it in. It has a tendency to smoke a little hot, and the cut in my ounce was choppy and thick enough that it needed relighting even after being well packed - but it's a delicious mouthful.

very mellow and has the aroma that pleased my wife.

This blend is an overall pleasure. If you smelled it you wouldn't think "peaches" but rather a general fruity aromatic. It burns evenly and tastes and smells great. Not as goopy as many blends (i.e. Captain Black). Try it.

Slightly better than Sutliff's Peach.

Smoke was good, not harsh and overall a good product.

Absolutely delicious. I went on a whim on this blend, who doesn't love peaches, and I am so grateful that I did, I was so enticed with a sense of summer and family and summertime enjoyments, The peach flavor is deep however not overpowering. This is a wonderful daytime smoke and people compliment on the aroma it produces. I stand by this that is a must have for any smoker. Brilliant!

Excellent for blending,smokes light and cool ,a little sour test near to 1/2 bowl.i do using for short puff or blending my own mixture -good with fruits combo or use your preferences...gets a lot better with time.

One of my favorites aromatics,always on rotation straight or blending with any thing...Can make a excellent fruit salad or pinch of this stuff can boost up even English or flake...I do use minty frost with some flakes also-game changer...

Overall very enjoyable but has a bit of a bite when freshly packed in my bowl.

Peter Stokkebye's Peaches and Creme is a very pleasant blend of tobacco. It smokes smooth and cool with a rich creamy flavor. This blend is easy on the tongue and could be an all day tobacco as well. This is a blend I am enjoying very much and I will be buying some more in the near future before I run out.

great Sutliff flavor, smokes very well, love it

A lillte wet. Nothing a little drying doesnt cure.

Best mild tobacco. Great taste

Delicious. Will definitely buy more

I found the peach flavoring to be artificial --- kind of like an air freshener, rather than a food flavoring. Sutliff makes some fine blends. This one wasn't my favorite, but I like many of their others.

My favor one.period.

Very nice, smooth tobacco. Nice aroma, peach taste. I'll be buying again.

Sweet smelling and sweet taste. My wife and I loved it so much that is part of our regular rotation of tobaccos.

Smooth Cool Smoke and Peachy Note for this sweet tooth ... was very nice for 'Breakfast" this morning :)

i have only been smoking tobacco for 6 months. I enjoy this tobacco. I expected a little bit more peach flavor. I was smoking it in a Roma pipe.

The taste is good , no bite Nice Smell, other people like the smell. I know I'll buy again.

Good aroma in pouch and room. Not my type of aromatic a little heavy on flavor.

I'm a peach nut! Peaches, peach tea, peach cobbler, etc. So had to try this. Just one more peach thing to love. Now I must add that I tried a couple other peach flavors from P&C and they weren't to my liking. This is "just peachy" enough but not overpowering. Have a jar and smoke a pipe full every day or two. If you're a peachy kind of person, give this a try.

When I'm in the mood for a sweet smoke, I love this one. Very smooth and no bitter taste.

This is some pretty good stuff. Second pipe tobacco I've ever tried. I definitely get some peach flavor as well as a sort of "cobbler" flavor, so the name is spot on. Definitely recommended.

Decided on a whim to give this one a try, but wasn't really a fan of the overly sweet peach flavor. If your an aromatic fan and like really sweet blends, this may be one for you to try. Reminded me of the Cube

It smokes pretty wet, even after letting it dry out. It has many more sticks and stems than my usual Newminster Blackberry Brandy. All around it is a fairly smooth smoke, just a hint of peach flavor comes through. Not bad, not great.

I really like this. I have always been a peach tobacco fan but this kind of takes to the next level. I ordered two ounces the first time just to try it. The next order was for eight ounces! Not sure I taste the dough and such but it is a more complex peach flavor. No candy peach taste here just a very smokable peach tobacco.

Incredible taste and smell.

This is one of the few blends I've found where the tin note, the room note, and the flavor line up. Mild. Sweet and peachy without being perfumy.

I have had plenty of aromatic tobaccos over the year. They all claim to taste and or smell like "Maple and Rum", "Irish Whiskey", "Coffee", etc. Most end up having a slightly accurate smell and a taste, while still pleasant, certainly isn't as advertized. I can honestly say that this tobacco lives up to its name. I was blown away by how I was actually greeted with a sweet, peachy taste and a pleasant, matching aroma. I will most certainly buy Sutliff again.

As usual my most recent order was completed and delivered very quickly and all items were delivered safe and sound.