MATCH Flying Dutchman

Close but not as 8I remember

Very close to the old Flying Dutchman.

Love the taste and has a pleasant and not to strong of smell it leaves in the room.

NOT LIKE THE ORIGINAL BUT NOT BAD.

Not as I remember it. Too harsh.

Like it very much, will order more.

would think about giving this a 5, which woud then say something, but am still evaluating

Just started smoking pipes again at age 74. Smoked them 45 years ago. I remember the orginal Flying Dutchman packaged in a tin. Loved it back then. Would switch off to a British tobacco occasionally but always returned to the over the counterflymong Dutchman. Your Match is close, but what I really miss was the very "fine cut" the original was sold as. That helped smoke bowl fulls to a fine powder there by aiding a perfect carbon cake build up. I will continue to smoke your as my primary tobacco, however if you ever decide to return to or add the fine cut, as the original, I'll be hooked on your match blend forever!!

Pros: Reminds me of the old Flying Dutchman out of the tin in the late 60's. It is close but not exact, the historic can filled with the fine ribbon, shag type tobacco had a more pungent order and taste, but this comes close . No bite, burns easy and smokes well, dry and cool. I used it to break in a couple of new pipes because it does burn cool and not hot, protecting a new pipe from burnout. Cons: Not a taste grabber, but I do enjoy the relaxed smoke. Not a regular but on rotation, will buy more when I finish the 4 ounces.

The burn is consistent and the smoke is a little on the warm side. The quality is high. It seems to have no casing or flavor added and you get to enjoy the high quality tobacco in its own right. It’s a bit high on the nicotine scale for me personally, not an every day smoker and it does leave your mouth and clothing smelling as if you just smoked a cigarette. My wife doesn’t enjoy its room note or lack of one but it is a high quality non flavored and would be great for an after dinner and before nightcap smoke or a bowl while it’s starting to snow.

The flavor of the Flying Dutchman is one of my favorites. This Match blend is high quality and I will order again.

Pretty close to how I remember it.

Nice. Good to experience it again. Flavor intensifies and very pleasant sweet notes surface as it is smoked.

Good Blend. To anyone taste testing tobaccos.....take it SLOW! Don't just smoke 1 pipe full and say or think you don't like it. You have to smoke 4-5 bowls. Try with and without filters. Try in the morning, afternoon and evening. Sip at the pipe. Don't Choo Choo away at it. Take a sip of your favorite beverage after every couple hits to clean your pallete. IMO most tobaccos don't taste great the first time you smoke them. Takes you, your taste buds and your brain some time to think about and realize what you are tasting. Only then can you appreciate the tobacco and decide Yay or Nay on wether you like or enjoy it. It never will happen with the first bowl or 1 bowl! I realized this early on as I bought all the tobaccos my pap smoked. Half&Half, Carter Hall, Prince Albert, SWR, Five Brothers. I sat down and smoked a bowl of each and all I could think was this stuff is HORRIBLE and what was my pap thinking. So I got online and researched Aros and English blends. Ordered about 30 of the top rated kinds. They show up in the mail and I began to try a pipe of each. Again as I'm going I'm thinking OMG all this stuff is just as bad as the American Blends! Even worse! After I'd tried them all....I had no choice but to try some for a second time. That's where things changed for me. As I did so I started to realize hey maybe this one isn't so bad after all. Then I tried it a 3rd 4th 5th time. Every time they became better and better tasting. Going back to the original American Blends I mentioned. As I tried them again I realized those are what I liked best. Your not gonna like all tobaccos. I'd say I LIKE 20% of them and LOVE 5% of them. But now I can Appreciate 100% of them!

OK, but not as good as original Has a good flavor

Flying Dutchman...not the Dutchmen i remember from days gone by.....however....very smooth, little to no bite. Very pleasing and not over powering to take center stage about all else in the room. I use this as an all day smoke and am very happy with it. I find with the order i had made on this....right from the bag with no air time for drying as many require.....this one, properly tamped.....the full bowl may need a re-light once....maybe. have found that after the first light up, take a couple puffs, let it go out. Then....tamp lightly, re-light and your on your way. The only 2 problems i have found with this smoke.....the bowl is never big enough to hold for the length of time you will want to smoke it. The second problem....minor....may have to change your filters a bit more often and keep the pipe clean !

I like it. Stands on it's own merits. It has a mild taste and aroma: no bite and doesn't boost the heart-rate by 20% (which is why, I suspect, many consume tobacco, that nicotine rush - not for me). I'm not a daily smoker... one bowl a couple times a week is enough. I've found it to be consistent. As for "match;" well, I can't say. The Dutch were fond of mixing all kinds of tobaccos - they were the first to do so on a large commercial basis in the 17th c. adding spices, berries, fruits, etc. Only a few of those old brands continue under the Danes (less inclined to experiment with exotic flavorings). But, it is what it is... and if a match, well and good. In the day (before Nixon took us off gold completely, disrupting the markets) I smoked all the Dutch brands I could find and liked them for their unique tobacco flavors, light on nicotine taste, and subtle aromas - this one is as good as any of those originals.

Growing up in thru 60,,s I smoked this about 1967 f&s was my favorite then fd & ch burly blends is about it some drug stores had some China black, so I feel in love with burly blends. Upon receiving my order opening it was the classic flying dutch man, after a few bowls full in my vintage briar pipes taste flavor ,room note lite vanilla, an a hint of sweet note wife loves it. If you want to experience we old codgers smoked buy a lightly smoked vintage briar pipe. Ebay great place to shop try some flying Dutchman. AND KICK BACK AND RELAX IN THE MOMENT. Rb

Nice change

Like it

Years ago I smoked Flying Dutchman as my main tobacco. In later years I moved away from my pipe to cigars and only in the past two years am I returning to my old pipes. To my dismay I find huge changes in the pipe tobacco landscape. Many blends I knew before are no longer sold along with my Flying Dutchman. I was hopeful when I saw that P&C were marketing a, I guess, reenactment. I tried it and it is very close to the original. However I have found a new love in Lane's Dark Red and will not be going to the 'new' Flying Dutchman. Try it though if you used to smoke the blend.

One of my all time favorite tobaccos. Takes a while to learn the best moisture content, but once you have that down the Flying Dutchman really has an awesome flavor and burns so nicely. I first smoked this wonderful blend back in “73” and am so pleased with the match blend. I can’t help but in-hail the wonderful smoke that it produces. It really gets me flying. Who ever mixed this match did a fantastic job. My hat is off to you sir. Did I mention that I am now 65 years old. The flavor does take me back to the “70”s. Keep up the good work. A slight licorice flavor would be a nice add in. Please try that.

Almost there needs to be tweet a little more can't but my finger on something missing, then 5 stars,it made think of the 70's Lou Apollo Beach ,FL

Quite good!

I remember it having a different taste. This tobacco is good but not like I remember The Dutchman from the 80s

Not bad but I do get a bit of tongue bite from this. It’s been over 50 years since I last smoked the original FD in college so I can’t really compare this with the original.

I remember this being smoked by friends of the family back in the 70s when I was a kid. This stuff has the exact same room note I remember and smokes well without the bite of the original as others have mentioned. Bonus star for being girlfriend approved as an indoor smoke.

Never believed I would ever smoke my beloved Flying Dutchman again but Match sure pulled it off. Too close to believe it was not the original. Thanks P&T!

good stuff, better than the original

Simple, sublime, perfect.

I cannot say enough about your level of service, and the quality of the Flying Dutchman. It is nice to know I can order and receive the order the next day. Very happy with your company and your service, and quality of your products.

What a wonderful codger blend! I've been pipe smoking for 40 years, and this is great. A wonderful tin note highlights the blend beautifully. Easy and tasty smoke. Highly recommend for anyone wanting to try a burley blend of the past days. Great job on the match

Good price and good tobacco. When I first started smoking a pipe, Flying Dutchman was my favorite. Glad I found a match.

It seems to have the taste of my old tobacco,but its been so long since i had it I'm not sure,but I think my taste buds would let me know, so I figure it must be close

Good stuff. Burn this all day!

Way to go P&C. Though I don't think this is a perfect match, it's as close as you are going to get with today's tobaccos. I used to use Flying Dutchman as rolling tobacco when I wanted a break from my red & white boxed factory made's. Some professors allowed smoking in the class room back then, and loved the aroma(as did class mates). I started smoking a pipe later in life after I gave up cigarettes, and have been looking for a good match for a long time. I have come close a few times with my own blends, but have fallen short. Thanks. Will order more.

Reminds me of the original, very smooth, not at all harsh in my vintage "THE PIPE" and reminds me of the 70's!

This is an all day blend that is pleasantly mild on the tongue with no bite and mild flavor. At first, the tobacco seemed much dryer than most aromatics, but easily packs and is as mild as any I’ve smoked.

Flying Dutchman Match, it is close to the original but lacks the full flavor and the aroma of the original Flying Dutchman. I suspect it is very hard to make a match with what is available today for the blenders. I started out in 65 smoking the original. My father always smoked it and I can remember my mother always set close to him when he did. The aroma was wonderful. He had mastered Flying Dutchman and taught me how to smoke it with out the burn. I still have six ounce of the original Flying Dutchman in a jar that I use on special occasions. My wife loves the aroma of it, and states the matches that I have tried, do not measure up to the original. I have heard that CCC makes a match that is very close, I have yet to try it because they can not ship to the state I live in. Will work on that.

Aye, I waited to place this review until I smoked a large nuff sample, so aft an ounce consumed here we go... The Flying Dutchman was one of the first tinned tobacco’s I smoked in the 70’s. Upon opening the bag, I bought 4oz, the aroma was wonderful. It has a light, sweet smell to it. The cut follows the original in the ribbons and cube. One main difference is the colour. The main memory I have is that the original held a lighter colour, not having any experience back in the ‘70’s. Now in thinking it may have had more oriental back then. Today’s blend looks like it has some black Cavendish instead. On first light the plumes of smoke were thick and tasty. It’s mild, with an even flavor all the way though to just over the bottom. The smoke gets a little wet about the half way mark. Just keep a pipe cleaner hand to keep dry. For a comparison to the original I’d have to say it stands alone. They are different and the same. Forty plus years is a long time to attempt a comparison between tobaccos. This is good enough on its own merits to be an enjoyable all day smoke. Buy it and see if you would agree.

Not bad burns well fairly mild smoke some tongue bit if you smoke to fast

I smoked a pipe in the 60s and loved the taste of this tobacco but couldn't smoke it because it scorched my mouth. This match blend is very good - not quite triumphant but good quality. The pouch note is almost herbal, slightly vanilla. The flavor is distinctly Danish mild aromatic. No nic-hit worth mentioning. I like mild tobaccos and don't like nicotine so this one works for me.

Tried out two ounces of this. Never had the original so no idea how it compares. Found this to be a lite and wispy smoke. Seemed to respond best sipped in a cob. Not bad. Has some teeth if pushed. Mild vanilla like taste. Holds its flavor throughout the bowl. Reminded a bit of captain black lite but with a bit more substance.

Mild, smooth smoke, but not enough character to be stand-alone; great mixture with more expensive blends.

Really a lovely mellow smoke. Better in all ways than the original I remember fondly from the 1960s. This is not as fine a ribbon cut as the original, but burns better and just as satisfying.

I’m relatively new to pipe smoking but I have tried many blends and I truly enjoy flying Dutchman I will re-order

slightly aromatic smooth smoke going to buy more

Well my memory of Flying Dutchman is 30 years old, so take this with a small grain of salt but I think it was cut differently, unlike another reviewer's memory of Flying Dutchman I remember it being a thinner ribbon cut or even a "shag" cut whereas the MATCH FD is somewhat more coarse and I don't it's think is a dead ringer for the flavor either. With that said however, this is a very nice aromatic that isn't too heavily cased and still tastes like tobacco. I've pretty much been smoking English/Balkan non aromatic blends for quite a while now and I can't really enjoy most of the goopy, heavy aromatics on the market today, this however is a pretty good one and I'll probably re-order this blend to serve as a change of pace from my usual English/Balkan blends.

The cut and top note flavor did not match that of what little I have of my remaining original blend. I was a bit disappointed. On its own, it is a pleasant smoke.

Pretty solid tobacco. Starts off simple but then gets more complex as you smoke it. I could see it as an all day smoke for some, but is missing a little something to keep me interested. Probably won't be buying again.

Good tasting and smooth smoke

EXCELLENT TOBACCO.

Good tobacco but NOT the Dutchman I remember. Weak tin note and no room note.

I haven't smoked Flying Dutchman in decades. The match, to me, did not come close to the original. Not a bad smoke but not like Flying Dutchman.

I can't tell you how many years ago I smoked Flying Dutchman. I do know that I've been away from pipe smoking for 15 years or more. I first became acquainted with Flying Dutchman back around 1966 when I first started smoking a pipe. I've always like this OTC pipe blend and thanks to you fine people it is here again in true flying colors. This blend is smooth, mild, enjoyable with no bite whatever. I do believe it is cut somewhat finer than the original was and this may even add to its wonderful characteristics. I ordered 6 different tobaccos in one shipment and Dutchman was one and believe it or not Dutchman was the very first I tried. You can bet this old man will be getting more of this wonderful match !!!

I really like this tobacco. I will be ordering more

It has been so many years since I was able to buy the original Dutchman that I can't say for sure that this an exact match. However, it does jog my memory as being very close and seems to have both the flavor and aroma of the original pretty well covered. I smoked a lot of Dutchman at the time and used it as a break-in and caking tobacco for new pipes because of its subtle sweet flavor and excellent caking properties. One advantage of this tobacco is that it has none of the original's bite. Dutchman would get extremely hot and bite if it wasn't smoked very slowly thanks to its very fine cut.This is becoming one of my regular rotation tobaccos and I'm enjoying both the tobacco and the memories that it has reminded me of. Now that I've found it, I hope it stays available.

WOW! Awesome!

One of my old time favorites that I was sad to see disappear from the shelves. Hats Off to the 'match' team...this blend is as how I remember the original from years ago.

Didn't realize this was available!! Awesome tobacco.

I wasn't old enough when the original flying Dutchman was out, but always wanted to try it. This tobacco burns nice, and has a great taste and roomnote. I will have this in my rotation now on.

I received my tobacco and just as you promised it is a replica of the original I used 40 years ago. The service was excellent just as the product. I will be shopping with you again.

Simply Awesome! Never had the original but this is very good.

Very pleasant, very lightly topped (cocoa chocolate?) aromatic. Pretty much a dead ringer for Prince Albert or Sir Walter Raleigh, but better. Never smoked the original.

will purchase more of this

I have no idea what the original tobacco was like but I can say that this is one terrific and satisfying smoke. It stays lit, the flavor remains pleasant and consistent. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

a tasty forgery!

Very happy to have found this blend. Flying Dutchman was my favorite for many years.

The tobacco was bland. Not what I expected. However, it has been many years since I last smoked FD. I will not be purchasing it again.

Dear Russ, I dare you to truly make this blend. As advertised it's 18 different types of tobacco blended together. You are a God compared to me but this is a true challenge. It's the table scraps of one company but yearly acceptable.

I was lucky enough to try some real Flying Dutchman some years ago and really liked it; then found out it was no longer available, which was a bummer. I found this match and it's pretty darn good. I enjoy it.

I was pleasantly surprised and enjoy the product. Not hot, burns long and smooth, no bite and nice aroma. Similar to the original. I would add a touch more vanilla. I'll buy more.

Flying Dutchman was one of my favorite mild, aromatic blends years back. When I came back to pipe smoking several years ago, I was sorry to find that it was no longer available although there are several "matches" available online. The P&G version is a very close match, and a wonderful blend in and of itself. I like to smoke a bowl at the end of my work day. I find it a powerful comfort that helps me think.

I ordered two different 15 ounce shipments, and they tasted totally different. The first shipment was the best, by comparison to the second shipment---which was very bland, tasteless and lacked the aroma of the first shipment. Then I found out through Customer Service that you "purchase" this tobacco already blended from another vendor, and don't actually blend it "in-house". If you did, you would have better quality control and probably much better consistency of the blend, by your Master Blender.

These guys have re-created my all time favorite tobacco...Flying Dutchman...to perfection! It is exactly as I remember it...Great Mix job!

When I first tried the Flying Dutchman Match, I thought it wasn't quite as I remembered Flying Dutchman. But, after smoking it a few times it became my favorite smoke. My wife loves the aroma in the house too!

great service, great product, great price, refreshing

Very impressive,just as I remembered.

Not anything like I remember it, but it may be due to 40+ years between "Flying Dutchman" smokes!

Not exactly a match. The taste is close and aroma about the same. Overall a great tobacco for the price !

Having never tried the original Flying Dutchman, I don't know how this compares. I will say however that this match was a relaxing smoke, stayed lit, and burned somewhat cool as long as I paced myself.