Great News, FREE SHIPPING now on orders over $79!
Back
To
Top
Something
Click the icons below for product information.

Something's Fishy

Something's Fishy around here at P&C. No, it is not actual fish it is yet another superb battle of the blends. In one corner we have Scotty's Salmon River which is composed of Burley blends with flavors and aroma of warm, sweet maple. In the other corner, we have Lane Buttered Rum which gives you the traditional sweet and zesty flavor of rum. Each pipe tobacco has something to offer to all those that are fans of sweet aromatic blends. But now we call on our P&C Faithful to help determine which is the best of Something's Fishy. At this time you can purchase both tobaccos at a low price and be able to smoke them side by side. Once you have tried them, come back and leave your review and tell us who the clear winner should be. 




Blend
PackIn StockPriceQtyCart
Pipe Tobacco SamplerOut Of Stock$12.99 Notify
Lane Limited Buttered Rum Bulk Shipping Constraints
Per OZIn Stock$2.58
Quantity:
Price:
1
$2.58
2-3
$2.44
4-7
$2.30
8-15
$2.15
16+
$2.06
Scotty's Salmon River Shipping Constraints
Per ozBackordered Notify$3.85
Quantity:
Price:
1
$3.85
2-3
$3.57
4-7
$3.33
8-15
$3.13
16+
$2.94
Shipping Constraints:
  • These items cannot be shipped to a Washington state address.
Add To Wish ListsLearn More
Overall Rating4.37 out of 5 Based on 101 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Something's Fishy”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
64
4 out of 5
4 Star
21
3 out of 5
3 Star
8
2 out of 5
2 Star
5
1 out of 5
1 Star
3
Showing 1-50 of 101 Reviews
5 out of 5
This is the second best
This is the second best next to Hazelnut with a close third 1Q
5 out of 5
Lane Limited butter rum bulk.
Smooth, cool and even burn. This tobacco is a Grand Slam. My new go to smoke.
4 out of 5
First thing in the morning smoke.
Not that you can't enjoy it all day but it's easy on the palate and great with a cup of coffee. Not moist at all but you need a good light to get it going. I think the reason is because it packs a little spongy. You obviously don't want to pack it to tight it just takes a little getting used to. It's one of the only aromatics I smoke by it self. The few aros I do smoke I usually mix with some virginia/burley tobacco like CD Briar Fox. This is very pleasant smoke with a smooth buttery taste and beneath the hint of spicy rum.
5 out of 5
A Real Buttered Rum
This one is not overbearing, but delightfully flavorful without any bite. The favorite of all of the Rums that I have smoked.
3 out of 5
I’ve smoked Rum Runner from
I’ve smoked Rum Runner from the Tinder Box for years and am looking for something comparable. This was drier than I am used to and I prefer the cavendish cut.
4 out of 5
Lane Butter Rum
Good at blending with unflavored blends..........
5 out of 5
Good Tobacco
New pipe smoker here. This is a smooth tobacco
5 out of 5
Scottys Salmon River
An equal to Trout Stream and Bass Pond, in other words a great aromatic.
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Very pleasantly surprised. Very nice flavor. Smokes well. One light is all I need.
5 out of 5
Give it a try!!!
Nice...
5 out of 5
Aromatic & Flavor
The tobacco was moist. When lit, it has a very aromatic smell that last a good while. The Burns if buttered rum is bar-none.
5 out of 5
I think I have finally
I think I have finally found my favorite tobacco after trying many many different kinds over the years. I highly recommend Scotty's Salmon River to anyone who wants a smooth, cool, satisfying smoke.
3 out of 5
change of pace
a nice change of pace tobacco, a little buttery at first but smothes out
5 out of 5
Buttered Rum
Fantastic, just like most from Lane...
5 out of 5
top notch
I'm, by no means, an expert, but, for me, buttered run is my favorite.. The smell, when I open the lid! The taste! As, Tony the tiger says, : It's Great."
3 out of 5
Not as good as Scotty's
Not as good as Scotty's trout stream.
5 out of 5
Great Match
Nice light maple flavor with Scotty's Salmon River, and Lane's Buttered Rum is very nice too, but I do like maple flavors more.
5 out of 5
Pleasant Maple Smoke
Good aromatic with no vanilla goop. It starts out mild but moves to medium half way down the bowl, burns clean and fresh with a pleasant maple flavor and aroma. This is a good one.
5 out of 5
Pleasant Maple Smoke
Good aromatic with no vanilla goop. It starts out mild but moves to medium half way down the bowl, burns clean and fresh with a pleasant maple flavor and aroma. This is a good one.
5 out of 5
humidar/cigars
love the humidar, still trying cigar samples
4 out of 5
Pretty good smoke
Nice. Smooth, no bite, not a strong aromatic, but has a pleasant room note.
4 out of 5
Nice all day smoke
Nice mild smoke. Suitable for all day smoking
5 out of 5
nice
a nice relaxing smoke esp now since its getting cold...nice flavors and room not...not haesh and no bite... will recommend this for anyone can't go wrong with Lane
5 out of 5
Very well constructed
A good alternative to Lane 1Q, fits nicely between the navy flake and the aromatics
5 out of 5
Scotty's samlon river.
Great smoke, all day smooth . Enjoy the freshness while relaxing by the river fishing.
5 out of 5
Smooth
Great flavor
5 out of 5
Lane buttered rum
Mild and mellow smoke very nice aroma
4 out of 5
A great evening smoke
I really like this tobacco from P&C. Excellent room note. Great front porch smoke.
3 out of 5
Little Bite
Not a bad blend a little to much bite for my liking others might like just my preference
5 out of 5
try it, you'll like it!
it's just a great smoke!
5 out of 5
Both Great!
However, Salmon River is the clear winner for me!
5 out of 5
It's gooood!
Love all of Scotty's fishy blends. Trout stream is our favorite and Salmon River is next! Just something so smooth, light, comforting and very smokable about both of these. Salmon River is great!
5 out of 5
Great flavor
Mild ,no bite ,a great maple touch .my personal favorite !
2 out of 5
It was ok. Not as
It was ok. Not as good as Trout Stream
5 out of 5
I smoke mostly Cavendish-based aromatics.
I smoke mostly Cavendish-based aromatics. I was not expecting salmon river to be as sweet or as smooth as it is nor was I expecting the aroma to be as pleasing as it is. I really enjoy salmon river and so does everyone else in the boat.
2 out of 5
Salmon river
Not so much tobacco flavor, casing reminiscent of chems.
5 out of 5
Magnificent Maple
The flavor reminds me of the taste of maple syrup mixed with melted butter that collects in the pockets on a hot waffle. Truly delightful. This ribbon cut comes at an ideal moisture level but could stand a little drying time for it to reach perfection. It packs easily, lights easily and burns fairly cool, even for an aromatic. If smoked gently but steadily, it burns all the way to the bottom of the bowl with few relits, if any, and leaves little to no dottle. Great on the river or just relaxing in your hammock on a Sunday morning (or any time).
5 out of 5
Supreme Subtlemess
I'm not big on Sutliff tobaccos of which this is one. With that said, I just ordered another pound of this!! Yes, ANOTHER pound. This is subtle all the way around. Subtle maple, subtle burley, subtle room note, etc. etc. It stays lit, is gentle if you don't puff like a locomotive and has become my all day tobacco. If you're not into "heavy" or syrupy, give this a try.
4 out of 5
Salmon River- kinda sorta like Trout Stream?!
I fill my bowl with Trout Stream and 1Q, (my 2 main "go to"). I tried Bass Stream and no likee. So when I saw Salmon River, I thought, "I like to fly fish for trout. smoke Trout Stream. I like to fly fish for Salmon so......" I got a few oz and fired it up. Not bad! A good smoke, not strong, no tongue bite. I dunno if it'll be my "all the time smoke", (That's 1-Q), but I'll burn this up and get more. Just my 2 cents!
5 out of 5
Excellent Quality
I purchased this for my dad and he is in love with the smell, texture and flavor. Excellent price and we will continue to shop here.
5 out of 5
Smoked ON the Salmon River and it was the perfect companion!
What a pleasant surprise! This tobacco delights me so. Every bowl is just as good as the last, if not better. Living near three rivers, I actually was able to smoke this one on the banks of the Salmon River and it couldn't have been more perfect a companion on a cool early spring day! Mellow, no tongue bite, nutty, tasty, and just the right amount of maple to wet the whistle!
5 out of 5
Smoother Draw
This brand has a very flavorful taste and an aroma that doesn't offend a non-smoker definitely worth the buy
3 out of 5
Dry
It was just to dry flavor was good.
5 out of 5
Smooth sailing on the river...
Very nice smoke. Scotty's Salmon River is aromatic, clean burn, no harsh taste. I purchased 3 other brands at the same however the only pipe I use is the one packed with Salmon River. You can't go wrong and will not be disappointed.
5 out of 5
excellent tobacco
Nice flavor & mild
5 out of 5
We love it!
A daily smoker. Smooth and sweet.
1 out of 5
Not as expected
Room note and flavor very mild next to none
5 out of 5
Lane Limited Buttered Rum Review
This sweet and mild blend is sure to be a favorite. It's amazingly buttery tin note and fantastic room note are top notch. Cool burning, delicious, and simply elegant.
5 out of 5
butter rum
i;m not much of a "flavor' guy I'll stick w/ Cavendish blends & lattikia
5 out of 5
great flavor.
really surprised with this one, one of my favorite now 5zzzzz.
5 out of 5
Great Smoke
Very mellow and smooth smoke with just a touch of sweetness. It lives up to its name and burns well.
5 out of 5
very nice
great flavor
5 out of 5
A favorite
Light, smooth, wonderful aroma. We think it's mellow but tasty.
5 out of 5
A winner.
If you want a smooth maple flavor with lots of creamy smoke, great taste and a delicious aroma, Scotty's Salmon River may be for you. You may get tired of people pestering you to ask what you are smoking and where they can get some, though.
5 out of 5
Tobacco
One of the best tobaccos that you sell. Mild no bite easy to pack. I would recommend it to everyone.
3 out of 5
Good blend
As usual good tobacco is used. I was hopping for more maple flavor, just wasn't there but I did enjoy the blend.
5 out of 5
Good tobacco
I tried a couple ounces of this to compare with C&D Autumn Evening and was very surprised. I liked it better. Great maple taste and aroma. You can still taste and smell it after the pipe has been put aside. Everytime I smoke a bowlful my wife has a craving for pancakes. Will definatly buy more.
5 out of 5
Great flavor
This has become one of my favorite tobaccos. In fact it is what I am smoking right now
4 out of 5
Nice relaxing smoke with a great flavor
Finely crafted subtle flavor makes it nice and easy on the palate, smooth - burns a little faster than Scotty's Bass Pond; nevertheless, good for a relaxing smoke.
5 out of 5
Better than expected
Lane always impresses with high quality at a reasonable price. I was not disappointed again. Not just a cheap rum infusion, but a quality smoke.
4 out of 5
Good, mild modest taste
Cool, pleasant smoke
4 out of 5
Good smoke but...
It can burn hot. Otherwise five star. tastes great and excellent room note. Get some.
2 out of 5
My husband did not care
My husband did not care for this flavor at all. But he has a friend who did enjoy the blend so it didn't go to waste.
4 out of 5
Very acceptable, except when outside,
Very acceptable, except when outside, with windy conditions, burns to hot. I only smoke outside.
5 out of 5
Lasting flavor
I just picked up a few ounces of Salmon river to try. I could fish my favorite trout stream and smoke my pipe all day with this blend. A nice mild smoke to the bottom of the bowl.
4 out of 5
Good burn.
Good burn. One light. Delicate flavor; did not detect much on first try, but I liked it.
5 out of 5
Really Nice
Tried a two ounce pack of this for curiosity sake. This is really nice! Mild, mellow and stays lit. The maple is certainly there but not over-powering and doesn't "bite" like so many other maples. I recommend it and will certainly order more.
5 out of 5
a heavenly blend . .
Lane's Limited Buttered Rum Bulk was a truly welcomed experience . . I blended it with several other of my long time favs & the result was a 'unique tasting and rich smoking pleasure' . . cannot wait to re-order.
5 out of 5
i have not tried it yet
the smell is nice and the taste is great when i do
4 out of 5
Good beginner tobacco
I like it - easy smoke - burns to a light ash - needs only one light - It would be 5 stars but it lacks distinction - very good but not stellar
5 out of 5
good all day smoke
Easy smoke - no bite - burns well - good aroma.
4 out of 5
Great smooth smoke
I like this a lot. It smokes well and smells great.
4 out of 5
Hello Maple!
For the most part, I am not one that smokes many blends that are primarily burley. But I ordered this one when I ordered the other new Scotty's aromatics. What a pleasant surprise! The maple casing is the dominant flavor with the tangy Virginia and the burley in the background - but still there. Lit well, smoked well, burned to the bottom with minimal relights. The pouch note is not bad, but the taste and room note was all maple and plenty of it. Good after taste and I smelled it for hours after smoking (I have a beard). In my book, better than Autum Evening.
4 out of 5
All maple...and plenty of it!
For the most part, I am not one that smokes many blends that are primarily burley. But I ordered this one when I ordered the other new Scotty's aromatics. What a pleasant surprise! The maple casing is the dominant flavor with the tangy Virginia and the burley in the background - but still there. Lit well, smoked well, burned to the bottom with minimal relights. The pouch note is not bad, but the taste and room note was all maple and plenty of it. Good after taste and I smelled it for hours after smoking (I have a beard). In my book, better than Autum Evening.
4 out of 5
Great tobacco
Nice smooth
4 out of 5
MILD
This one is on the mild side as far as flavor. The flavor is subtle, yet delicious. It does seem to be a bit on the drier side, and is useful for blending with other stronger flavors to calm them down, and for adding to wetter tobaccos to help balance the moisture level.
2 out of 5
Too mild
Very little flavor, and it leaves a strange film in your mouth. Its almost too mild to taste.
5 out of 5
Love it, very mild -
Love it, very mild - great flavor.
4 out of 5
Lane makes good blends
Good blend, just a little too much bite for me though. Typical of flavoured blends.
5 out of 5
Sweet Butter Rum...Yum!
Very Nice...smooth and tasty.
1 out of 5
No Good
This smells like buttered rum when you open the bag. After a few puffs it leaves a "film" inside your mouth. It made me mildly nauseous.
1 out of 5
Horrendous
Horrendous. It smells wonderful until you smoke it. Bitterness galore. Bites soft then hard. Coats your mouth in an ashy burned liquid fakers that took 500 rinses to get put. Putting this where is belongs. In the trash.
5 out of 5
Lane's Buttered Rum Heaven
Lane's Buttered Rum is a very smooth blend, with just the right amount of sweetness that it still allows that buttered rum goodness.
5 out of 5
Lane Buttered Rum Bulk
I enjoy smoking the Buttered Rum pipe tobacco. It is a smooth blend with a nice aroma.
5 out of 5
Awesome smoke!
Rum flavored smoke has always been my favorite, and this by far is my favorite! will defiantly order more!
5 out of 5
very light mild and tasty
very light mild and tasty
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Great smoke with wonderful aroma. Great for all aromatic smokers. Two thumbs up
4 out of 5
Wonderful Aromatic
Like a lot of Lane tobaccos, this one will not disappoint. If you like aromatics you should try this one.
5 out of 5
Lane Buttered rum
this is best buttered rum tobacco I'v had and I smoke it everyday all day and there is no bite it smokes cool try it you like it a lot
5 out of 5
Love it
Love it - my go to pipe tobacco
3 out of 5
Lane vs Sutliff Buttered Rum
I generally like Lane tobys and have for about 4 decades, but this one is way to subtle for me ... prefer the Sutliff Buttered ... also like Sutliff's Sunset Rum for its sort of "Rum Taffy" flavor and notes.
5 out of 5
Smooth and cool
New to pipe smoking but this stuff is cool smoking, smooth, and makes for a great smoking experience, especially with a cup of coffee!
5 out of 5
Buttered rum
One of my favorite flavors, smooth, simple and slightly aromatic
5 out of 5
Great service and product
I first tried a small order of the Lae Buttered Rum and found it much milder than the less expensive Smoker's Pride. My re-order was handles promptly and was exactly what and when expected.
3 out of 5
Enjoyable but not outstanding smoke.
When I first started smoking a pipe I found a small shop in Texarkana that sold a buttered rum tobacco that was quite literally "lip-smackingly good". I've never enjoyed any tobacco as much as that and have been looking for another source for it for years. I had hoped this might be the one, but it's not. Not that the Lane's Buttered Rum is a bad smoke, it's just not a great smoke. The aroma in the pouch is "tasty", you almost want to eat it, yet the smoke is very mild in both odor and taste. If you like a mild, easy burning smoke, this may be a good choice for you.
4 out of 5
Smooth
Very smooth nice slow smoke.
5 out of 5
Bought a Pound. I need more
This blend got a very high rating from me. I always let new blends sit in my in house office for a couple of days or so before I smoke them. I filled up a well cleaned pipe and let it sit for a couple of moments and then fired the pipe up. Unlike many aromatic blends, I found this blend to burn well, with the room note being very pleasant. The draw on the pipe was excellent and the mixture continued to smoked freely . I am very happy I bought a pound of this to cellar. Burely blends are for a relaxing, calming smoke, the epitome of smooth and mellow. Lane's Buttered Rum fills the bill exactly, and for me, it was a very pleasant, tasty, and relaxing smoke. i strongly reccomend this blend as filling a burley aro mixture exactly. Kudos to Lane. You've hit a home run.
2 out of 5
dick geuss
I just cannot get into those flavored tobacco...although I must admit that my wife liked the aroma.
4 out of 5
Would recommend
Great aroma with a slow burn and subtle flavor.
5 out of 5
Great after resting
When I first tried this, I hated it. It burned hot and just not much flavor. As I learned, I left this sit in the bag(you could jar) for 2 months. Now it's mellowed and wonderful. You now can taste the rum.
5 out of 5
Satisfied Customer
I'm enjoying the Lane Buttered Rum.
CLICK HERE to learn how to get FREE SHIPPING on your entire order!