Sutliff Buttered Rum is one of their most popular blends and has been for years. Select Burleys and Virginias are combined with the essences of New England and Jamaican rums, with a creamy, buttery, sweet note added. The flavor is smooth and subtle, and the room note is amazing. If you like the tangy sweetness of rum, you should try Sutliff Buttered Rum.
Really good, just not my favorite. I really love the vanilla custard
4 out of 5
I'll buy it again
Jul 23, 2021
I like this and will order it again. I like rum and this didn't disappoint. Not bitter, no after taste, etc.
4 out of 5
Solid 4 stars
Jul 18, 2021
Not sure what I was expecting but it wasn't this. It is good just not the flavor of was expecting. I would buy it again though.
4 out of 5
A good tasting tobacco, but
Jun 16, 2021
A good tasting tobacco, but a bit on the moist side. Hard to keep lit.
5 out of 5
Great smoke
May 27, 2021
Great smoke
5 out of 5
Very nice! Definitely will buy
Apr 24, 2021
Very nice! Definitely will buy again!
4 out of 5
Better tabacco than first expected,
Mar 29, 2021
Better tabacco than first expected, good flavor and room scent. Burns nice
4 out of 5
As with most Sutliff tobaccos,
Mar 02, 2021
As with most Sutliff tobaccos, it's a reasonably smooth smoke and has a great aroma and taste. A very nice tobacco. Highly recommended.
3 out of 5
Bland
Feb 28, 2021
Tin note - nice, easy to smell creamy/rum. Room note - disappointed, the tin notes were not present. Taste - bland, little/no "buttered rum" taste, not unpleasant just missing flavor. Misc - nice cut, this has been the driest blend from Sutliff I have tried, ironically it was hard to keep lit. Will not buy again, probably will not finish bag, still on the hunt for a nice rum blend...
5 out of 5
Nice taste
Feb 26, 2021
Nice taste
4 out of 5
Mild bite...delightful flavor and pleasing
Feb 23, 2021
Mild bite...delightful flavor and pleasing room note
3 out of 5
RUM!
Jan 24, 2021
I smoke Lane 1Q everyday, this has a good rum smell and taste (not artificial). I had to dry it out in the open for a few hours to get it stay lite and to prevent tongue bite. One filter per bowl, as it does leave some heavy goo behind in the bowl and filter. I enjoy it, and will buy it again, nice change.
5 out of 5
It's all excellent so far.
Jan 12, 2021
It's all excellent so far.
5 out of 5
Nice
Dec 29, 2020
This was a treat for me. The flavor of this tobacco was nice and the aroma filled the room with joy.
3 out of 5
Okay
Dec 25, 2020
Okay
5 out of 5
This is, again a great
Dec 17, 2020
This is, again a great flavor! Pipes and Cigars never fails! I loved it!
5 out of 5
Nice aromatic
Dec 02, 2020
Great rum flavor and no bite. Good aromatic.
5 out of 5
Lightly flavored,pleasant smoke
Nov 14, 2020
Lightly flavored,pleasant smoke
5 out of 5
SUTLIFF BUTTERED RUM
Oct 25, 2020
THIS IS AN AWESOME SMOKE! GREAT FLAVOR AND AROMA!
4 out of 5
Love it
Sep 29, 2020
One of my favorites so far. The room note and aroma are awesome. The flavor is spot on. A great smoke! Even the price was excellent!
5 out of 5
I really enjoy
Sep 23, 2020
I really enjoy all Sutliff tobacco including Buttered Rum
5 out of 5
Must buy
Sep 21, 2020
Amazing aroma and decent taste. Still new to the pipe tobacco, but this is going to be one I buy often. I have tested other rum and this one if by far my favorite.
5 out of 5
Love me some ButteredRum
Sep 01, 2020
I started enjoying a pipe a few years ago, tried several brands/flavors... then I came across Sutliffs Buttered Rum ☺️
I Really enjoy puffing this in my pipp...
Glad I found Pipes n Cigars too, once the C19 hit... I was at a loss for where to get my fix, then I found you guys 😁
5 out of 5
Good.
Aug 29, 2020
Good.
3 out of 5
Good, but not great.
Aug 01, 2020
It was OK, but not what I was hoping for. My top two aromatics is Lane 1-Q and Scotty's Trout Stream. This does not come close to being as good as those, but it was a pleasant smoke; no bite, good bag note, and room note.
4 out of 5
Sutliff Butter Rum
Jul 20, 2020
smocks nice
5 out of 5
Sutliff buttered rum
Jun 22, 2020
Good smoke, not harsh and a very aromatic room note, definitely on the rotation
5 out of 5
Very nice
Feb 17, 2020
Mello and sweet smoke, one of my new favorites.
4 out of 5
What is in a name? Sutliff has lived up in this offering!
Feb 12, 2020
My first foray into Sutliff offerings has left me craving more. Well flavored, heavenly room note, NO bite when smoked gently, and everything I imagined “buttered rum” tobacco to be. This is my ‘treat’ tobacco each night as I settle my nerves for rest. For those, as I, who cut their teeth on Lane 1Q, but had a hard time enjoying the weight when inhaled, give this wonderful aromatic a try.
5 out of 5
Great flavor and not too sweet
Jan 22, 2020
The Sutliff Buttered Rum is a good go to tobacco that works well with any drink from coffee to bourbon. If your looking for something sweeter this is a great choice.
4 out of 5
Good flavor and behaves well
Jan 13, 2020
Good flavor and behaves well in the pipe
4 out of 5
Smokes well nice aroma packs
Dec 31, 2019
Smokes well nice aroma packs good
5 out of 5
Very flavorful pipe tobacco
Nov 30, 2019
Very good pipe tobacco, the smell in the bag is absolutely delicious and smoking it was equally as delicious and will definitely buy again.
5 out of 5
Very flavorful
Nov 19, 2019
I really like how flavorful this tobacco is, as soon as I received my bag of it I could smell it and it smells delicious and was an absolute treat to smoke. I definitely will be buying it again in the future and will be happy every time.
5 out of 5
Enjoyable smoke
Oct 12, 2019
Bought this for my father inlaw. He said it was his favorite and it was an enjoyable smoke.
5 out of 5
The aroma was fantastic, the
Sep 26, 2019
The aroma was fantastic, the flavor was subtle but was overall enjoyable. It burns well and leaves a great room note. I would recommend if just to try.
4 out of 5
Smooth and very nice aromatic
Aug 13, 2019
Smooth and very nice aromatic tobacco
4 out of 5
Good value tobacco
Jul 06, 2019
Easy smoking, pleasant (but not strong) room note, not too much tongue bite. Price too good to pass up
4 out of 5
Not Bad Alone but Better as a Mix
Jul 04, 2019
This is not a bad aromatic. It's reasonably mild, if you do not puff too hard it will not bite. The tin note is very nice as is the room note. Unfortunately the flavor could be punched up a little. So if you like a strong rum flavor, look elsewhere. I usually mix this (50/50) with Sutliff's Sunset Rum which has a darker rum flavor and a hint of vanilla. It also helps it smoke cooler and a little slower. The mixture basically becomes a good bulk substitute for Sutliff's Barbados Plantation.
3 out of 5
Not bad.
Jun 21, 2019
It didn't have the flavor punch that I was expecting. I am sure others whom have a more delicate pallet taste more than I do. It is quality tobacco though.
4 out of 5
Not bad
May 04, 2019
Burns a little quick for my taste. Really can't taste it. Still good for mixing with Queen Anne's Revenge
4 out of 5
Sutliff Buttered Rum
Feb 09, 2019
This tobacco is my favorite. It has mild flavor, a modest, but detectable room note. However, if you are a puffer, you will likely encounter, an inordinate amount of heat and bite. If, on the other hand, you smoke leisurely (is there any other way to smoke a pipe?) Sutliff's Buttered Rum is a delectable treat.
5 out of 5
Yum, Buttered Rum
Dec 31, 2018
Very nice sweet flavor and aroma.
5 out of 5
Very nice smoke. Smooth and
Dec 25, 2018
Very nice smoke. Smooth and easy to light and it stays lit
5 out of 5
Great smoke!
Nov 07, 2018
Great smoke!
1 out of 5
Harsh, bites, not a pleasant aroma or taste.
Oct 06, 2018
Like Sutliff's Rum and Maple, this tobacco was strong, harsh, and the aroma was not as expected - nor was the taste. Will NOT buy again, and after these two, I will be very leery of the Sutliff brand -
5 out of 5
Buttered rum
Aug 26, 2018
Smooth mild smoke with pleasant aroma's
5 out of 5
good choice
Aug 11, 2018
I like it and will recommend it to others.
4 out of 5
Buttered Rum
Jun 18, 2018
Mild and flavorful.
4 out of 5
A mild smoke
Jun 14, 2018
A pleasant mild aromatic
5 out of 5
Very nice!
Mar 05, 2018
A pleasant and tasty smoke! Pleasure to enjoy any time of the day.
5 out of 5
Sutliff Buttered Rum
Feb 25, 2018
Mix it with Decatur Dark sweet rum. Nice smoke.
4 out of 5
Pretty smooth with nice soft notes. Will buy again.
Feb 04, 2018
Pretty smooth with nice soft notes. Will buy again.
5 out of 5
buttered rum tobacco
Jan 24, 2018
great
3 out of 5
Mild and mellow
Jan 01, 2018
Not as bright a flavor as I was hoping for but still an excellent smoke. The slower you smoke it the more flavor you pick up. Good room note.
3 out of 5
3 Stars? WHAT!
Nov 22, 2017
This tobacco has an awesome tin note! it stays lit well. It does smoke well no gurgle or tongue bite. So why 3 stars? Well I like aromatics like Molto Dolche and Chocolate Mousse by Sutliff. They are VERY VERY sweet with lots of flavor in the smoke. To me thats what an aromatic should be a very flavorful smoke. I just dont get that from Buttered Rum. it smells great but the taste just isn't strong enough for me. So if you want an intensely sweet heavily cased aromatic you may want to skip this one. By the way Sutliff is by far my favorite brand to smoke and this is a great tobacco but for me it is not sweet enough or flavorful enough.
3 out of 5
3 Stars? WHAT!
Nov 22, 2017
This tobacco has an awesome tin note! it stays lit well. It does smoke well no gurgle or tongue bite. So why 3 stars? Well I like aromatics like Molto Dolche and Chocolate Mousse by Sutliff. They are VERY VERY sweet with lots of flavor in the smoke. To me thats what an aromatic should be a very flavorful smoke. I just dont get that from Buttered Rum. it smells great but the taste just isn't strong enough for me. So if you want an intensely sweet heavily cased aromatic you may want to skip this one. By the way Sutliff is by far my favorite brand to smoke and this is a great tobacco but for me it is not sweet enough or flavorful enough.
5 out of 5
Great!
Nov 15, 2017
I gave this a try and really enjoyed it. I will definitely buy more when I finish what I have. I did not taste the rum so much, but it is definitely in the aroma. The butter flavor however is very pronounced. Not so much a sickly movie theater flavor, but rather fresh butter from the farm.
5 out of 5
Great rum flavor in a good smoke
Jul 24, 2017
Great flavor profile! Good nose and a nice room note. By far the best buttered rum IMHO. My local shop carries this and I also buy it here. My go to daily smoke in the late afternoon or early evening. Light it up in my reconditioned Grabow and let the day close out. Great all day smoke with no bite. Great with a cup of strong coffee to start off the day.
5 out of 5
Sutliff Buttered Rum
Feb 06, 2017
good and smooth. noticeable and bold
5 out of 5
Smooth as silk
Jan 02, 2017
Excellent fast and burns evenly. A nice every day tobacco that tastes and smells wonderful. It's my new favorite!
5 out of 5
great smoke
Nov 12, 2016
When you smoke this tobacco everyone around you loves it too
1 out of 5
Harsh.
Oct 18, 2016
Though the category was "mild". We found it harsh.
5 out of 5
Wonderful product
Oct 06, 2016
Great tobacco, tastes great, smells wonderful
5 out of 5
A very good smoke!
Jul 21, 2016
I found Sutliff Buttered Rum to be a very smooth, nice tasting blend. No tongue bite whatsoever. It has a pleasant room note that is not overpowering or overwhelming, just nice. I really enjoyed this blend.
5 out of 5
Smooth Smoking
Jul 14, 2016
I think the Sutliff Buttered Rum tobacco is great. It doesn't have a lot of flavor to it, but it's an extremely smooth smoke with no bitterness at all. I just wish it was as cheap as the other brand I buy, which is half the price of the Buttered Rum.
5 out of 5
Sutliff Buttered Rum
Jun 06, 2016
Great tobacco! No bite and tastes good.
5 out of 5
In the occasional rotation not not my top all time.
Jun 03, 2016
I really enjoyed this one. It was more subtle than my top from these guys- Vanilla Custard. I have it as my occasional stock for certain.
5 out of 5
Tasty
Jun 02, 2016
Very tasty, no bite, nice after smell, burns great
5 out of 5
Great pipe tobacco
May 04, 2016
This is my go-to pipe tobacco. I have converted a few friends to this choice.
5 out of 5
This is a Better Buttered!
Apr 03, 2016
Form, Sutliff's Buttered is better than Lane's Buttered.
5 out of 5
Hot Sutliff Buttered Rum
Apr 02, 2016
Like it better than other Butters. Good by itself and mixed with Sutliff Sunset Rum for a more Carmel or Toffee flavor and note. Who me? I ain't no sweet tooth!
5 out of 5
Rum!
Feb 27, 2016
It's like i'm smoking rum! Delicious blend!
5 out of 5
Very tasty
Dec 10, 2015
I find this to be a very tasty blend with a warm and pleasant room note. I love it!
5 out of 5
Pipe tobacco
Oct 22, 2015
The sutliff buttered rum tobacco was superb.
The flavor and aroma is a pleasure to smoke.
Thank you for such a great product!
- brant
5 out of 5
BUTTERED RUM FIND
Oct 12, 2015
My ex had been looking for a certain blend he had smoked and bought in a pipe shop in Dallas the pipe shop closed so he has been trying to find something comparable to that tobacco, he ordered 3 samples of different blends and found that this was the closest to what he used to smoke, he said the aroma is great and it doesn't smell bad at all. He is so happy he has finally found something he can enjoy in his pipe again has already ordered the second bag,
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Sep 30, 2015
Very mild with just enough sweet flavor. Mellow after taste.
5 out of 5
Last order
Sep 07, 2015
Good tobacco and order came quickly.
Customer Testimonials
This will be my second order for Sutliff Buttered Rum. Oddly enough, availability of similar tobaccos is nonexistent in my area! This tobacco is one of my all time favorites.
GM of Cincinnati, OH
Excellent tobacco, just placing my second order now. The densest smokey clouds of all my blends, great buttery sweet room note, creamy with a bit of spice on the tongue. My favorite for blowing smoke rings.
BC of Holly, MI
Buttered rum is one of my favorites. It smokes fairly cool and has quite a mild bite. It has an excellent taste and only a small amount of lingering smoker's breath. The aroma is pleasant, although it is not my wife's favorite. It smokes well in both my briar and corncob pipes.
By providing my email address, I agree to receive special offers by email from Pipes and Cigars.
No purchase necessary. Click here for contest rules.
Click here for contest winners.
Privacy Policy.
Sign Up for Email Specials
