3 out of 5
Price is right for 16 oz.
5 out of 5
Tastes great,smells great,great value
5 out of 5
My favorite! Lots of complex flavor and aroma. I wish this came as an aftershave lotion or cologne.
3 out of 5
this is actually quite good after a drying out. this is coming to the top of my rotation for an all day smoker
5 out of 5
Always good tobacco. Great price for a great product.
5 out of 5
Excellent tobacco for the price. No tongue bite. Low room note. Recommend. Excellent for blending.
4 out of 5
It is a smooth tasting smoke with little to no bite. I've enjoyed it for the past two years,
5 out of 5
Always a good deal.
4 out of 5
Best of the rest..is good for home infusion of flavors.
3 out of 5
He said it was ok but he keeps looking for something like Wonder Blend Black Cavendish that he smoked years ago and can't find right now.
5 out of 5
All day pipe when working in the shop
5 out of 5
I have always enjoyed the blend, the aroma and it's a real pleasure to smoke. I have never really tasted a bitter or a bite of this mix, always a great smoke. Thank you for a great deal.
3 out of 5
Came in quite dry; however, a little time in my jar humidor and it was fine. Smokes wonderfully and the room notes are awesome. Great value.
3 out of 5
Not nearly as good as the English blend of this mixture but I don't hate it either
4 out of 5
Very nice smoke
5 out of 5
A good smoke, not to wet, and smells good.
4 out of 5
Well, it's a good filler. You can smoke it, but it needs something more to make it more like a tobacco for everyday use.
I blended half a pound of this with a half pound of Mac Barens 7 seas regular that I put up in April 2018 (what, you don't let some blends age for 5 years?).
Turned out very nice with a better smoke and room note than even I expected.and will last a long time.
I have many others at the 5 year mark that I'll try blending with the remainder.
5 out of 5
Best of the Rest
4 out of 5
ordered capt black for years. getting higher than a cats back. the Best of the Rest works for me at less than half the costs.
5 out of 5
A++++ Will purchase again.
5 out of 5
Smooth, fragrant and satisfying. Certain this is, by far, the BEST tobacco I have smoked in this price range!
5 out of 5
It's great, price is right, shipping is quick, what's not to like.
5 out of 5
This is some of the best tobacco I have tried and it’s different every time, very fun me interesting.
5 out of 5
Good all-around flavor moisture contact is great use it every day nice mild smoke great price
4 out of 5
Mellow. Well worth the price. The 7/16 oz. bags will lst a long time.
5 out of 5
Very smooth with just the right amount of moisture. Great taste and aroma.
5 out of 5
Very good for the price
5 out of 5
Excellent budget priced tobacco, certainly not budget quality. Lights and burns well without any harshness, pleasant taste. I usually prefer non aromatics however this is an exception, anxious to try the english blend.
Equates to a single barrel bourbon!
5 out of 5
I am extremely pleased with this package. The Roma pipe is well made and it smokes smooth. I guess the real surprise was the lighter. I have a drawer full of pipe lighters some very expensive some bargains and none really well. I reluctantly fueled up the Pipe and Cigar lighter and tried it out. It really works! I have been using it for two weeks and am really impressed.
4 out of 5
It is ok lots of stems
5 out of 5
In fact, I'd go as far as to say it's even better. A perfectly blended, perfectly balanced and hydrated smoke.
5 out of 5
Very enjoyable and reasonably priced!
5 out of 5
My #1 go to. Cheap smokes mild. Good aroma.
5 out of 5
Great value here.
5 out of 5
always a bargain when moneys tight Best of the best is just right
4 out of 5
Too moist. Would not stay lit. Normally excellent but the two bag on this shipment too moist. Will continue to buy.
5 out of 5
First time I tried it. Very impressed, will purchase again. Smokes cool and room note very nice.
5 out of 5
Very good smoke. No bite.
5 out of 5
GREAT quality & price.
Smokes fine.
5 out of 5
Good clean smoke, aromatic!
4 out of 5
my pipe likes it...
5 out of 5
This is my 2nd bag both were good in different ways. Over all it's a cheep way to have good tobacco. Much higher quality than I've ever been able to get for even close to this price. Will buy again
5 out of 5
Mild smoke, good aroma.
4 out of 5
I am pleasantly surprised by how this smokes. The price is spot on. I think I will continue buying 'Best of the Rest' after I finish off the tobacco I received for my birthday.
5 out of 5
Its good!!!!, I like it, flavorful!!
5 out of 5
I found the Best of the Rest to be a smooth mild aromatic blend, a very enjoyable smoke, very good room. I'm very pleased and will definitely order more.
5 out of 5
I use to buy from you for a long time your Walter Raleigh aromatic, This is very good ! Thank you !!!!
Hope to buy it again next month
4 out of 5
always satisfying as a basis for mixed tobaccos
4 out of 5
Pleasantly surprised with this order. Mild bite. Aroma not overpowering nor unpleasant. And flavor is subtle with a slightly sweet overtone. I will order again.
4 out of 5
Expecting longer leaves but for the price it is a value
4 out of 5
good for the price
5 out of 5
Great burn and smooth taste
5 out of 5
Was moist,nice flavor,great price$$$$
5 out of 5
I ordered this because of the price. I tried some of as soon as I received it. I'm very pleased with the aroma. It has no bite and is very smooth. I will order it again when use it up. I hope I get a similar mix on my next order.
5 out of 5
Smooth. Smells good and ship fast.
5 out of 5
Only blend for me. Everybody loves the fragrance
5 out of 5
Very enjoyable smoke
4 out of 5
Great price...good smoke
4 out of 5
Smokes ok for inexpensive brand.
5 out of 5
Great price, very good quality, assume deal!
4 out of 5
I ordered both the Aromatic and English versions and my review of them is below:
1. Both blends I received were a nice ribbon cut.
2. Both blends were a bit moist right out of the bag and smoked best with a little bit of drying time.
3. The Aromatic wasn't goopy or overly sweet. Tobacco flavor came through nicely. No tongue bite. Reminded me of Lane 1Q.
4. The English was what I would call a light English. By no means a Lat Bomb but definitely there. I found it to be a very pleasant smoke.
Would I order again? Yes. I realize the next batch will probably be different than the batch reviewed here, but that's ok. From this experience Best of the Rest is one of the best deals for a pipe smoker.
4 out of 5
What can I say? For what it IS, it's not bad. It's basically your standard ribbon cut super value tobacco, like Gambler, or Four Aces brand. The "roll your own" pipe tobacco that comes in regular, menthol, and light? (I call it "pipe" tobacco, because were it anything else, it would be taxed differently). Anyway, it's that, but flavor infused. I wouldn't really call it an AROMATIC but I wouldn't be opposed to calling it flavored super value.
It's like if you entered a neighborhood contest of best flavor infused "roll your own" pipe tobacco, and it won. So you took that pipe tobacco and entered it into a nationwide contest of best aromatic pipe tobaccos, alongside Captain Black, Borkum Riff, Sutliff, Mac Baren, and Half Half, and they sort of laughed at you and made you and made you take your product and join the audience, even though back in the neighborhood it still gets a weird sort of respect, you see.
In fact, if you're looking to really stretch your dollar, you could probably blend this with some quality aromatics, and it would still be quite pleasant to the general public, because by itself, the aroma isn't bad. It has some bite, but it's surprisingly low for what it is. After blending, you wouldn't really notice it much (if at all).
I guess what I'm trying to say is, this is probably one of the best tasting, most well balanced "filler" tobaccos I've had, but I wouldn't want to smoke it by itself. That's probably why they call it "Best of THE REST". 😉
5 out of 5
I smoke a lot. This 16 ounce bag will last me 5 weeks. Best part about it, it's good! Medium flavor, nice aroma, doesn't bite the tongue. Way better than a bag of that stuff you would buy in a smoke shop (you know, the stuff that tastes like pencil shavings). There are better tasting and better smelling tobaccos that cost 8 times as much, but this is my go-to tobacco. I also like the English blend, but my family complains about the aroma, so I stick with this.
5 out of 5
The name says it all. Best but for the price.
5 out of 5
Everything was fine. Service/shipping was fast and on time. Is there some way I could find out about when your tobacco goes on sale?
5 out of 5
Pleasantly surprised by this bargain mixture. I have the aromatic version. To my taste a quality smoke. I know it may be different next time but expect it will still be an outstanding value.
4 out of 5
Beginning pipe smoker here. This is very smokeable, not to harsh, a little sweet. And a bargain. Very enjoyable.
5 out of 5
New piper here so I am not an expert but this tobacco deserves 5 stars for the price. The blend is pleasant and the moisture is perfect. I am smoking 1/2 now and cellaring the rest in mason jars.
4 out of 5
Good buy
Usually good mix and moist
Best price for me
Years ago capt black was my favorite. Way out of my budget now.
4 out of 5
Can't beat the price.all round a good blend of tabbaco.will buy again and again
5 out of 5
Best deal around.. Thanks!👍
1 out of 5
The aroma was fine. It burned well. The problem is the taste, or lack thereof. Pencil shavings would have been more flavorful and less harsh.
5 out of 5
My everyday smoke. Great flavor and pleasing aroma all at a very reasonable price.
4 out of 5
I like vanilla aromatic blends and this had enough tones and aroma to fill that need. It did have a bit of a bite, but not too much. Only problem I had was trouble keeping it lit, but for the amount you get ... at that price, you can't go wrong.
5 out of 5
First time buyer of this blend. Usually smoke Lane's or the Danish Black but I am really enjoying this and it is amazing value for the price. Nice steady burn to the bottom with almost no bite, nice flavor and my wife allows me to smoke it !!
Obviously not a "to die for" tobacco but a genuinely enjoyable bowlvevery time at a great price point.
4 out of 5
It has become standard for to order a bag with every purchase. Good every day/all day kinda smoke. Better than the price suggests!
5 out of 5
Very good pipe tobacco product use daily.
5 out of 5
Fantastic every day smoke. Smooth and full bodied but not too sharp. I recommend this for a baseline to smoke daily.
5 out of 5
VeryGoodWillBuyItAgain!!!!
5 out of 5
My husband loves this tobacco, he said it is mild and lasts in his pipe. He used to order Russ candy corn but it has been unavailable lately. This is a very nice replacement and a much better price.
5 out of 5
This is my first review. I have been thoroughly satisfied with the Best of the rest aromatic blend. It’s unlike anything I’ve smoked honestly. It’s flavor is neither this or that, but rather just something special that I will likely buy often because the mix is different with each bag. At a pound of tobacco for this price? Why wouldn’t you try it? It’s the best deal you can find anywhere, and I promise you won’t be disappointed. The bag arrived ready to smoke, I threw it in my corn cob and went after it.
4 out of 5
Its fresh and better smoke than the bagged stuff you buy at smokin'joes. For the price you can't go wrong.
5 out of 5
Happens to be one of my absolute favorites. Very very consistent with flavor, smoke, room note and moisture level. It’s a bit warmer if a smoke which I personally enjoy.
4 out of 5
I haven't had a bad bag of Best of the Rest yet. The inner resealable part usually comes loose from the bag too easily but some sprayed on water brings the tobacco back into shape.
5 out of 5
Great price,taste and love the smoke.
5 out of 5
This can’t be beat! Very enjoyable all day long....or good with a port in the evenings.
5 out of 5
The best of the rest is very flavorful pipe tobacco. Not to mild not to strong. Good go to blend. Doesn't get boring. Smoke it slow. Will bite
5 out of 5
This is always my favorite tobacco, just like coffee I like to try different ones everytime I order, but it doesn't matter how much money I have spent on other brands this value priced and packaged tobacco has actually always been my favorite, and when I order a tabacco that I don't enjoy too much, I use this one to mix with it.
5 out of 5
Always an enjoyable blend. Best bang for your buck!
5 out of 5
I've been smoking Best of the Rest since 2019 and still to this day. I tend to stay with the products I like and I can afford. This is by far the Best price and a whole bag can last me a whole month. Makes me very happy. Hopefully wen I am able I want to try out some of the other tobacco. Maybe this month I might try the Norman Rockwell.
4 out of 5
Excellent value for the money
5 out of 5
Delicious aroma and taste, good bad size and great quantity for the value. I will purchase again. Thanks
4 out of 5
Really good flavor and a great deal
5 out of 5
Very nice tobacco. Especially considering the price.
Mellow, burns really nicely - not too hot or fast. It seems perfectly moist, but doesn't load up the pipe stem with water like some drier/harsher tobaccos I've tried.
The scent and flavor fresh out of the bag is a little vague - I have no idea how I'd describe it. It's not my favorite, but it's also not overpowering. And as this will likely change batch to batch I won't knock it.
All in all a very nice tobacco and a relaxing, everyday smoke.
5 out of 5
This is a fantastic pipe smoking tobacco. The amount that you get is absolutely amazing for the price. The surprise about the amount that you get is fantastic for the money that you spend.
It smells good and taste good.
5 out of 5
My first bag. I will order again. Smokes good all the way to the bottom of the bowl.
5 out of 5
Smooth flavorful
5 out of 5
Absolutely wonderful 😄
5 out of 5
This is a very nice mellow tob,,,nice aroma that isnt too strong.Who knows which vanillas this is made up of but this is GREAT product for the money.A lil bit sweet,,nice amount of vanilla.This 1 is mild enough that you can puff this all day long.
5 out of 5
Nice aroma, no bite and an easy everyday smoke. Fast shipping and always great service
5 out of 5
Nice tones , holds a nice moisture and smokes great.
5 out of 5
Is a good quality tobacco, The favor are good also and the quantity for the price is reasonable, I recomend it.
5 out of 5
I have always enjoyed the aroma and the moisture of this tobacco. Has always been a great smoke.
5 out of 5
Smells good, very nice room note!!!
5 out of 5
My every day smoke. At a great price.
5 out of 5
Great product, best prices, trust seller. Thanks
5 out of 5
I like the smoothness! no bite
My friende like the Smell ! , nice taste
5 out of 5
Cannot beat Best of the Rest
5 out of 5
I'm about to purchased my tenth or so one-pound bag. I usually mix this 50-50 by weight with any decent black cavendish (whatever you'd enjoy by itself), then load it into clean jelly jars with tight lids, slap a date label on the jar, and squirrel them away in my tobacco cabinet. It's been fun, when sharing this with friends who come over to join me for a bowl or two in my well-ventilated man cave, to ask them what they think of my private blend. Maybe they're all just super polite? 'Cause they usually thank me for sharing my obviously expensive tobacco with them. Some won't believe me when I tell them what I just told you!
For plentiful and super affordable bowls of smoking pleasure, give this a try.
5 out of 5
Perfect title for an amazing pipe tobacco. You will not be disappointed with this buy. Fast delivery as well. ‘Pipes and Cigars’ is my new first choice place to buy my tobacco products. Thank you.
5 out of 5
The aromatic bag I received didn't appear to be mixed but has a very nice flavor and burns well. Tastes much like Sutliff maple walnut. I know the mixture changes from bag to bag , but still a good deal. This is my first time buying Best of the rest but won't be my last.
5 out of 5
Super value for a very good (while not great) tobacco.
Hard to beat the quality even at twice the price.
5 out of 5
Great! Best deal out there.
4 out of 5
I've probably smoked 3 pounds of this tobacco and every one had a different smell outta the bag--once even smelled kinda flowery? lol but dang--it always smokes sooo smooth and cool --end up finishing the bag and wishing I had more--for the price you can't go wrong--best smoked in one of your less expensive pipes like a Missouri meerschaum because it may impart a aromatic scent to your pipe but still a great smoke to try
5 out of 5
Love this stuff easy alday smoke.
5 out of 5
Great price,nice flavor and aroma,good every day smoke,
Will buy again
5 out of 5
Best of the best tobacco is real moist and smooth I highly recommended this is a good product best of the best tobacco
4 out of 5
Got a pound last year as a bonus to my order. Smooth and dependable. I smoke this while working in the yard. Good enough that I ordered another pound.
5 out of 5
I love it. And get mad at myself wen i forget to buy another bag. It can last me a whole month.
5 out of 5
I am guilty. Very guilty of snobbing this blend for quite some time. I tried for the first time today. It was a mild aromatic with hints of caramel and vanilla. No tongue bite and very pleasant.
5 out of 5
Bought ‘Best of the Rest’ for years. Very satisfied with it, mild and tasty.
5 out of 5
I bought it for RYO. I blended 1 third of OHM turkish and 2 thirds of BOTR. I didn't have to dry it out since it came with the perfect amount of humidity to be rolled once it was mixed. Very smooth, aromatic, slow burning, and a very nice flavor. I thought it will come with weird mixed flavors but no, it is homogeneous; a perfect and subtle aromatic pipe tobacco blend. Definitely buying this again !!
4 out of 5
Meets my needs and is reasonably priced. Shipping time is very good.
5 out of 5
I’m on my third bag, I always try to place the flavor quick before it changes & my mind most consistently goes to Nutella spread (hazelnut cocoa). I’m not experienced enough to begin placing exactly what ends up in here but with my budget I know the taste of cheap aromatics & this ain’t that. Keep this stuff flying off the shelves so it stays at this price! Will try the English next.
5 out of 5
Real smooth, smoke all day - no bite
5 out of 5
Can't smoke the English version due to allergy to Latakia, but the so-called
"Aromatic" Best of the Rest smells great and smokes cool.
\\
4 out of 5
Pretty good smoke for the cost.
5 out of 5
we all like the room note
5 out of 5
I quit smoking aromatics years ago. I got this bag free as part of a promo deal, and it has refreshed my interest in the genre. This is a really nice blend with notes of cherry and vanilla. It's not cloyingly sweet, and smokes clean. If I ever run out (it's a big bag) I will buy another. Of course free is the best price, but the list price is pretty great too.
4 out of 5
Good burn and taste.
5 out of 5
Great bargain for an everyday smoke
4 out of 5
A .tasty, smooth smoke, long cut with a fresh brewed cocoa hint to the room note. No bite but not mild either. I smoke it straight from the bag but mixing has good results, also.
4 out of 5
Best of the Rest has been my go to tobacco for several years. Smooth, mildly aromatic, good all day smoke. Sometimes a little on the moist side and the resealable bags don't. That said it's my #1 go to tobacco.
5 out of 5
I love this tobacco.
4 out of 5
Great value for the money...says its a mix match but I think mine was just some kind of generic vanilla. Hardly any bite, looke to be of quality tobacco, mine smelt like vanilla cake throughout entire bag. Not a bad gig at all.
4 out of 5
looking at the online descriptions... It seems like everything but the kitchen sink used in this blend.
It was a great price, and a good friend told me about it. So I thought I'd give it a whirl...
I honestly didn't expect much.
Boy was I surprised....
Mama always said this tobacco was like a box of chocolates....
You never know what you are going to get...
No way to describe it. The flavor and aroma not only transition between bowls. BUT BETWEEN HITS.
A very tasty and high quality tobacco.
I would definitely recommended this one and I will be purchasing a lot more at that price.
Excellent job guys.
5 out of 5
Quality product, smokes great & the price is great. Thanks for introducing it to me. Will be purchasing it again.
3 out of 5
There ok most are packed to tight for me.
4 out of 5
Doesn't burn as long as other similar brands I bought.
5 out of 5
I first bought this tobacco to add to my Lane 1Q to extend my quantity. I tried a couple of smokes right out of the package and was so impressed by the taste that I smoke it as a stand alone tobacco and ordered more with my next purchase. The price and quality of taste is a real bargain!
4 out of 5
Great value for the price. Always a welcome also
5 out of 5
Always my go-to tobacco. Price is right, and has never disappointed.
4 out of 5
i liked this brand and will order more
4 out of 5
Dunno what its made from but i like it,not as much as i like Captain Black Gold,but its a lot cheaper so i intend to think of it as my fall back Tobacco maybe ill alternate every month
4 out of 5
AS YOU WOULD EXPECT, IT IS DIFFERENT WITH EACH ORDER. MOST ARE VERY SATISFACTORY. FOR THE PRICE, IT'S WORTH IT.
5 out of 5
Absolutely amazed with the low low bite very smooth on the draw smokes great and has a changing flavor that is pleasing and surprisingly satisfying taste great will reorder
5 out of 5
A good economic smoke. No bite, burns just right.
5 out of 5
You can't beat it
5 out of 5
I like it while, I enjoy wondering how, the good price, along with, taste that, I'm gaining with every draw, will not go quickly.
5 out of 5
I've now had my BOTR for just over a year,at first was very comparable to 1Q when my palate was a little less developed..but now,this blend SOARS above my first impressions.. it's slightly bolder,nuttier,the Virginia content in mine is very up front, Burley is very nutty,earthy,it has a slight plum/peach and smokiness too.im VERY pleased with this blend...still have 8oz.unopened in a jar over a year..gonna be great.
5 out of 5
This bag was better than the first bag I ordered
The first bag came in a plain plastic bag and the only thing I could taste was menthol.had to doctor it up to make it palatable. frankly i think they screwed the order up and sent me cigarette tobacco. This time it came in the proper bag and it actually tastes like pipe tobacco.
5 out of 5
I Like it well Enough to Buy another Bag ,It's Pleasently Mild and Flavorful enough to be a New standard order item to have in my cabinet for a Break from my Aromatics and Cavendish infused regulars...Makes for a Good Starter Pipe Smoke...
3 out of 5
Best of the very Best O.K. but not for long term smoking .
5 out of 5
I wasnt sure what to think of this blend at first. Threw a bag in the cart since they were running a deal for free shipping with any order with a LB of this stuff. Man was i surprised and couldnt be happier with this purchase! Have tried MANY tobaccos in the 2 years or so i have been on the pipe and in that time have tried a number of aromatics and every other kind as well. The bag i recieved tastes like a single blend rather than just a BAG OF SCRAPS, it has a Carmel note to it and is not a GOOPY AROMATIC and burns perfectly perhaps one of the best burning aromatics i have tried. Have recieved numerous compliments on the room note scent from total strangers. Took about a OZ with me on a recent camping trip and really got to know this blend during that time. It is sweet not not cloying and will not cause diabetes lol This is one i wish i had picked up another LB since i have no idea if it changes over time but will be jarring up some of this stuff for future use, highly recommended to anyone that likes a sweet change of pace or something to add to other tobaccos to help either the burn rate or add a bit of flavor.
5 out of 5
Love your products.
5 out of 5
good pipe tobacco
4 out of 5
taste is fine, not ny cut,too fine and stringy
5 out of 5
It came free with my pipe so the price was right. Not bad at all, I rather enjoy it. No tongue bite, smooth and flavorful. I would probably purchase it in the future. If you like mild aromatics, then this will suit you fine.
3 out of 5
Good - but not on my list of favorites
5 out of 5
Used this blend for many years, not over powering or harsh
5 out of 5
Quality product at a great price. Also, timely deliveries
4 out of 5
Have purchased capt black here for years. Tried diff blends at pipesandcigars, some more, some less expensive than capt black. Saw Best of the Rest. Debated for two days before ordering. At half the price of the capt black I had real reservations on the quality. I pulled the plug and ordered. I am delighted at the quality. I will reorder when running low.
5 out of 5
A pretty decent smoke! I don't know if it's true, that this is "floor sweepings" (leftovers, combined), but the net effect is a fairly cool, mild and flavorful smoke. I generally smoke a Black Cavendish, and this is less flavorful...but very nice, for a Change. No harsh Bite, stays lit without trouble, there's a lot to like about this Blend. Especially at this Sale price, it's a No-Brainer! I am very pleased with this purchase. 16 oz. should last me awhile, too. :)
5 out of 5
What the HAY is this ? Was very, very hesitant all this time, saw the Best of The Rest bags on P&C but thought it would be a crapper. Only got my first bag because it was free. Opened the bag, delightful aroma, packed a bowl as usually will, lit up, and WOW, was I surprised. Excellent flavor, aroma, moisture content, everything was really good. Sad thing was, as I'm puffing away, I can see a can of Sir Walter Raleigh Aromatic sitting on my coffee table, and although SWR is a great smoking blend, I'm wondering why I spend so much on it when BOTR was there all along at a MORE THAN REASONABLE price.
5 out of 5
Very impressed, I amazed how tasty and smooth this blend is , no tongue bite at all . I did let it dry out a hour though first . Then jarring the rest for later . Can’t wait to get another bag for back up .
5 out of 5
Been buying from these guys for years and they never disappoint.
5 out of 5
I am on a limited budget so i have always smoked the cheapest tobacco on the market. I was finally able to try this and cant believe what ive been missing! im sold on it now! Best smoke ive ever had! No more cheap stuff for me
5 out of 5
Great smoke at a bargain price.
5 out of 5
Each bag is it's own unique blend. I have yet to be disappointed.
5 out of 5
For the money, it’s satisfies my taste bud,,smooth...plus, being an old guy on a small pension, I can’t do any better, oh,and it doesn’t bite. Very good value. Bob
4 out of 5
Was very surprised at the flavor great job. I am looking forward to the next blend to see what the difference might be.
4 out of 5
The batch I got is a little on the dry side, but not bad. It's aromatic and flavorful enough, without being harsh. And it's a great value.
5 out of 5
good smoke for the money. I got one unmarked bag and was not as good.
5 out of 5
Great product at a very reasonable price.
4 out of 5
Ilike it very much, very mild and good aroma
5 out of 5
Always enjoy this tobacco. It has good flavor and is mild enough I can smoke it all evening.
5 out of 5
Best of the Rest is my daily go to tobacco. Great taste and quality at a great price.
4 out of 5
Not bad pipe tobacco for the price.
5 out of 5
Great smoke with smooth finish. I would recommend it to those who smoke pipes for a value product that is good.
5 out of 5
Each bag is a little unique. Maybe more sweet, maybe more fruity. It is truly a great value and I have been smoking it for many months, regularly.
4 out of 5
I have been buying this blend for a long time now. The older type of blend was good, but I believe the new way of dividing the tobaccos is better. I am not an english smoker, so not having the chance any is in the blend is better to me.
5 out of 5
I have never been disappointed with this blend
4 out of 5
pleasant aromatic good all day long
5 out of 5
My husband really likes this .It's a little different each time and he says it's a very good smoke.
5 out of 5
Great smoke for the price, no tongue bite, burns even, it’s my go to tobacco
4 out of 5
I really did not expect much, then it showed up in what looked like a super value pipe tobacco bag and I thought I made a big mistake. I am probably 10 t 15 bowls in and I am pleasantly surprised. I took one start off because no mater what pipe I use or how clean said pipe is I do get a little pipe spit, and I do not smoke a hot bowl. Outside of that no complaints.
5 out of 5
Always a surprise, and always awesome
3 out of 5
OK aromatic. Not great but OK. I remember just getting tired of smoking it and wanting to smoke English. But it changes all the time so I might give it a go again. Give it 3.5 stars.
5 out of 5
I'm very pleased with my BOTR pound. Expected sub par mix..but after a couple of bowls, I would suggest this to any Piper that enjoys a flavorful, light aromatic with combination of flavors that can't be easily deciphered...I get chocolate,vanilla,rum,anise,fruit,and other undecipherable flavors(so far) with a slight smoky,peppery,effect..this is a finely cut easily packable, cool burning, perfectly humidified blend.Looking forward to enjoying this over many months as it matures and continues to morph it's flavors.
5 out of 5
Affordable, and has a great taste. Burns nicely.
4 out of 5
There seems to be less “flake” and only “cigarette cut” faster burning tobacco. Years ago there was a variety of tobacco in the bag. Not much variety today.
5 out of 5
Very good tobacco, mellow and mild. This will now be my "daily go to ". Hope the blend stays consistant.
4 out of 5
P&C n' m go way way back . . some 15 yrs now . .service has always been 'on point' . I've enjoyed experimenting with new tobacco . . always fresh and I get what I ordered . . several times 'every month' . . BUT . . . I just placed an order and seems like I'm not worthy for the 20% off . . ouch . . that hurt
4 out of 5
This tobacco is as good as any of the more expensive brands and is well worth the price.
3 out of 5
Was a good everyday smoke.
5 out of 5
works for me, keep it in stock!
5 out of 5
I'm well into my first bag now and I'm really enjoying it. Some of my old favorite flavors with buttery, nutty notes. It's a nice mild blend that smokes well and taste great. I've already ordered another bag.
4 out of 5
Good tobacco for a small price
5 out of 5
A really satisfying aromatic blend. Much more than I expected. The Best indeed.
5 out of 5
Tried this stuff for the first time and was great
5 out of 5
A great and flavorful all day smoke! Give it a try, I don't think that you will be disappointed...
5 out of 5
EXCELLENT FRESH FLAVORFUL. IF YOUR A TOBACCO SNOB DON'T BOTHER IT DOESN'T HAVE A FANCY NAME BUT IF YOU WANT A NICE NUTTY EVERY DAY SMOKE THAT WON'T BREAK THE BANK THIS IS AN OUTSTANDING BARGAIN.
3 out of 5
Great value definitely smokable
5 out of 5
The rest must be good, cuz the Best of Rest is! A balanced aromatic that satisfies.
5 out of 5
both blends great for the money
4 out of 5
good price and good tobacco!
4 out of 5
fresh the day it arrived. its a nice smoke and better than anything off a store shelf at a good price. Well worth trying for smokers of all types.
3 out of 5
Sometimes this is a great smoke with the perfect moisture content, other times it isn't so good. Last batch had a touch of latikia which I am not fond of and it was a bit to the dry side, the time before it was perfect. I will continue to take my chances simply because it is the best deal going
5 out of 5
Try it until you try it!
5 out of 5
Loved it, I ordered it some time ago and I have been enjoying it ever since. Granted I was hesitant due to it being leftovers from the bulk bagging process. But it was a great mix. Kinda reminded me of the tobacco I used to get from my local shop called North Sea.
3 out of 5
P&C needs to change their product description and be honest with customers. P&C no longer collects their own leftovers, but buys "leftovers" from manufacturers. My last order of BOTR was packaged by Lane. The product may be fine for many customers, but the source is not as advertised.
5 out of 5
Has a pleasant vanilla odor out of the pouch and after lighting with more of a cigar vanilla tone. The flavor is a sweet vanilla. For the price to quantity ratio, you cannot beat the deal.
4 out of 5
Satisfied, smooth and didn't get hot like some other tobacco products.
4 out of 5
This is a great weekday, after work smoke. I will definitely purchase again.
5 out of 5
Really good tobaccos for the same price as the budget brands, always a unique blend... Like gettin the mystery sucker in the bag.
4 out of 5
Mild and cool burn, not much flavor
5 out of 5
I was surprised, very good. Smoked all over the world. It's a great day smoke.
5 out of 5
Good value and good quality
5 out of 5
Very pleased with all around service....
4 out of 5
very satisfying smoke. I purposely dry it out some to make it burn slowly and stay lit. This was my 5th adventure with "Best" some are better than others but I liked them all.
5 out of 5
This is a mild blend of favors. Since trying it, it has become my everyday smoke. I really like its smoothness. I have smoked 5 one pound packages of it and will continue to order it.
5 out of 5
worth it good flavor
5 out of 5
I received my tobacco today and it is so amazingly good! The products and service of this company are the best! As if a nice pipe of tobacco and stroll was not enough to remember my grandfather and honor his memory, people stop and comment on how rare a sight it is. People who are involved in cell phones 24/7 are everywhere. A gentleman with a pipe stops traffic in an otherwise weary world.
5 out of 5
Been ordering this for years. Always smooth and robust at the same time. Highly recommend for the regular piper that's cost conscious.
4 out of 5
I have bought a dozen different types of pipe tobaccos from this store and although this one is extremely cheap it is actually one of my favorites so far. I don't know how much the flavor will differ from month to month, but I will definitely try it again next time I need some.
4 out of 5
Not as mild as I thought it would be, but still a good smoke.
5 out of 5
Good smoke. Great price.
5 out of 5
This is the perfect tobacco for me. From the first puff I knew I found my favorite. Very smooth and easy to smoke.
3 out of 5
Is this a mixture of different tobacco or a weak selling brand. It always seem to b exactly the same.
5 out of 5
This is a good all around smoke. It is on the mild to medium side and burns nicely with a good flavor and a pleasant aroma.
4 out of 5
A good everyday smoke. Great value.
5 out of 5
I smoke often over the course of the day and was looking for an all day smoke that was economical and also a quality tobacco.................well I found it! BOTR lights and smokes easy, has no bite, tastes good, and is the right moisture (does not arrive too wet or too dry) and for the price I can afford to smoke it all day.
4 out of 5
tasted pretty good, when u factor in the price it tastes great. it has a little bite
5 out of 5
Best of the Rest is a smooth smoking product
4 out of 5
Not bad tobacco! I did have to add some Black Cavendish to this because the burly was biting. It smoked pretty cool afterwards.
4 out of 5
Oh, for the good old days! When best of the rest was the made from the leftovers from the mixing table and different each time you ordered! While it is still good and a good value (I order regularly) it is consistent and not a surprise anymore. I guess that's what has too happen when something get too popular to be made in small batches.
5 out of 5
Good tobacco good price fun flavors
5 out of 5
It is a good tobacco on its own. I would advise not adding anything to it. Bought four bags a few months back and really liked it.
5 out of 5
For the most part I love it
1 out of 5
Zero taste. Shredded to death. Burned hot and fast.
5 out of 5
I don't believe BOTR is really a hodgepodge of tobacco, it's too evenly cut and blended and each order had been identical. Many products out there are marketed as "seconds" or "surplus" when in fact they are manufactured for such marketing. That being said, I tried it and love it, and will definitely buy again. It seems to be a high quality, it's very aromatic and flavorful and absolutely no bite. At a pound for this price, you cannot go wrong. Happy piping, all!
5 out of 5
smokes good plan to buy more
5 out of 5
Deff will order again.
5 out of 5
Great product fantastic price and the shipping was resonable and right on time Thanks
5 out of 5
I ALWAYS ORDER “THE BEST OF THE REST” AND PERHAPS ANOTHER PIPE TOBACCO TO SWITCH TO. I ALSO LIKE THE DECATUR PIPE CLEANERS AND THE MEDICO FILTERS. THANK YOU.
5 out of 5
Excellent tobacco!. I would recommend this tobacco to any pipe smoker.
5 out of 5
For the price this is really nice, would expect to pay more for tobacco this good. Thanks P&C you folks are great, R
4 out of 5
Bit more aro than I usually smoke but the wife likes it, she says it makes her think of Girl Scout Cookies thin mints
4 out of 5
I generally prefer English but thought I would give this a try. Not bad, my wife likes it, says it smells lie Girl Scout Thin Mints.
5 out of 5
Got my first bag yesterday. Nice aroma and flavor; stringy vanilla & other like blends,
without a tongue bite. Enjoyable.
5 out of 5
I BOUGHT THREE BAGS OF THIS AND BEGAN MIXING MOST OF THIS IN JARS WITH OTHER TINS. BEEN USING IT MOSTLY FOR SEEING HOW LONG I CAN USE IT. TO MY SURPRISE IT SEEMS TO GET BETTER WITH AGE. I GOT ABOUT A BAG STILL LEFT.
5 out of 5
Tried it out a couple years ago and liked it so much it's the only one I buy now. Try to buy early in the week because it seems to include lighter blends as opposed to the dark that tends to burn.
5 out of 5
I have found this to be one of the best, smoothest smoke and flavor I have tried.
I prefer Vanilla Cavendish in any brand with a strong vanilla aroma.
5 out of 5
I will always have some on hand. Great flavor. Great price.
5 out of 5
My husband really enjoys the smoke.He gets compliments from everyone.I enjoy the aroma in the house.
5 out of 5
VERY GOOD LIKED THE CHANGE FROM LANE Q1
5 out of 5
I like to create my own blends. Best of the Rest represents a quality tobacco at a reasonable price that I use for my base blending tobacco.
4 out of 5
It was very nice, but nothing really special. I enjoyed it and have smoked it all, but would probably not buy it again.
5 out of 5
It's been a few years since I last tried BofTR and this is a terrific batch. More like a regular blend than a mix of leftovers, a nice surprise. Apparently it now comes direct from Lane. If you're looking for a working in the garage (but quality) smoke this is a fine choice. Can't beat the $$!
5 out of 5
Mild smooth smoking tobacco at a reasonable price.
3 out of 5
When this was actually the "best of the rest" when Russ was blending, I received some very good blends. Never quite the same - but always good, and usually tending toward the natural English type of smoke. The last two orders - I have received "commercial bags" of cheap tobacco - not terrible, but far from the quality I had grown to expect. Will be looking for a better "cheap" smoke.
1 out of 5
The very first 16 oz bag I had was great. I was happy as all get out! I rationed it out over a 4 month period just so I could thoroughly enjoy at special times.
I was so impressed, I ordered two one-pound bags. Wow. Both bags were totally different and both "terrible". One bag was very dark and woody. Stems were present in every pinch. The taste and aroma were close to what I assume Alfalfa would taste like. Totally unsatisfactory. It bit my tongue with a pain similar to a staple inserted.
The second bag was a lighter blend and yes the taste was similar to a very bad cigar! It was only after that that I was informed how it was collected and what it was. Read the description very carefully, that is my caution.
5 out of 5
This is a premium tobacco at a fire sale price. I'll be ordering again.
5 out of 5
Very little tongue bite if you know what your doing, good taste.
5 out of 5
This is my second order and enjoying a good smoke again.
3 out of 5
Not as good, and more expensive, than it used to be. But it's as good as I can afford.
5 out of 5
Always got the right product and very quickly
5 out of 5
On my THIRD order of "Best of the Rest". Have tried over 30 samples of other product. Some of the best, ones I like, are Captains Blacks Varieties. None of them are better than "Best of The Rest ! If you blend it you spoil it. Only one other comes cloase and that is Captain Black's Bronz. Having said that, it (Bronz) is much more costly. Best of the REST is now my ONLY brand.
4 out of 5
For 16oz of quality tobacco this is a great deal ... better than average smoke for sure ...
5 out of 5
Currently smoking my fourth order of BOTR. I really appreciate the new packaging. The first two orders arrived in their simple zip top bags, and were horrible dry. Once properly hydrated, they smoked very nice. With the new packaging, the tobacco arrives very moist, and smokeable immediately. I was a little hesitant in the beginning, with the first order, figuring the quality might be a bit underwhelming. I was SO wrong. Its been a good, all-day smoke. Great flavor, and aroma. This won't be my last order for BOTR! And again, I love the new packaging.
5 out of 5
By far the Best shredded blend ever. It is my main smoke, mild, flavorful and aromatic.
4 out of 5
Got my package today, delivered day earlier than expected. Upon opening the box, I got note of chocolate 1st, which was surprising considering I had 6 oz of Latakia blends in same box. I have tried 1 bowl so far. NIce room note, easy burning down to fine white ash. Little more of an Aro than I usually smoke but will plan on buying again. Great price and the Mrs. likes the room note even though she described it as thin mints (Girlscout cookies).
5 out of 5
Good smoke, good variety, good price
5 out of 5
Not my first experience with this mixed base pipe tobacco. Every batch has been slightly different but every time "very tasty" and in good condition. The price is very reasonable as well. Try a pound with an open mind and enjoy.
Steve
Bentonville Arkansas
5 out of 5
A well balanced smoke with the right mix of sweet and buttery, with a little heat thrown in.
I prefer the ribbon cut and find this blend better than any drugstore brand. I'll continue buying if it stays this good!
4 out of 5
Every bag i tried was just as good - or better than other economy brands i tried. Had several bags that were just as good as the high priced brand names. Best table scraps i ever had !
4 out of 5
The price is right! What I got looks like ribbon cut Virginia with a good dose of Vanilla. Can't detect any other tobaccos in this bag. It does have good flavor and it burns to a light gray ash. It is a little moist straight out of the bag. I'm thinking this is made up of not so much end of the day as it is the machine cutting of one particular tobacco. That being said, if the bags were consistently like this one, it would still be a super bargain.
5 out of 5
I've bought 2 bags and so far it's been great. Looking forward to buying more in the future.
5 out of 5
Great. Totally love this mild, aromatic, tasty blend. Highly recommend!
4 out of 5
Trying this was a superb pleasure. Mild, mellow and aromatic. Burns slow and consistent.
I was surprised about the price for the one pound as it fit the budget while providing hours of enjoyment.
5 out of 5
I got this tobacco and it tasted kind of chocolatey and nutty and you could tell it was a mix of different tobaccos. Every bowl was great from the time I lit a bowl to the time it was ashes!! Sucks that it changes though😕 the blend I got would be what I always buy!! But I'm sure knowing pipes and cigars, that every bag is descent!! Very happy to have found this tobacco!! Thanks p&c for making tobacco for people who can't afford expensive tobacco!!
4 out of 5
Very mild with a pleasing Aroma. Good burn and light ash. Worth more than the current price.
5 out of 5
Best tobacco available for the price. Great burn, easy pack and fantastic aroma.!
5 out of 5
Was looking for an everyday blend, just to be available but never expected this flavorful, even burning gem of tobacco.
4 out of 5
First time purchasing BOR, could not wait to try it. Looks like ribbon cut Virginia, plus? Smokes nice a very slight bite, still enjoyable. That is the reason 4 stars. Super fast delivery, ordered tues. received on fri. WOW! P&C is back in the groove. Super!
5 out of 5
The bag I received about week ago is just what was hoping for. It smokes great. The variety of tones is perfect. My everyday tobacco has been CARTER HALL years, but I may have switch to this. I have tried it in my briars, meerschaums, and my corncobs (I have about 30 pipes).
2 out of 5
I liked the Best of the Rest when I felt it was actually what it was said to be-left over or unlabeled tobacco. This bag has all the earmarks of farming the task out to a third party and seems to mainly consist of long shredded cigarette tobacco.
I'll try this once more, but if it's the same product I'll jut order something else.
Customer Testimonials